Shane_McWannabe
Active member
Even though I personally did not like the edit, I have to give it up to Mr. Bishop for presenting the most coherent and intelligent argument in this thread. It is good to see him in the fray of this, he doesn't have to do that. Obviously he has strong views on this subject, like most people who are posting do.
The thing for me is that I actually view this edit as 'conforming'. Not conforming to the stereotypical skier image, but conforming to a much broader social movement. Are the ideas presented in this edit unique to FDwear? No. Where did FDwear get these ideas from? What makes people in general think that the image portrayed is badass? I think to most people the answer is fairly obvious.
The plane, the cars / drifting, the guns, the money throwing, the club scene....nothing here is breaking the mold, they are merely trying to fit a much broader mold onto the sub-culture of skiing. No doubt rap videos have inspired many of the social ideas we encounter everyday, how is ripping one off 'breaking the mold'?
I don't think the creation of this sport was as much a phenomenon as some people would like to believe. People had skis, snowboard parks were built at ski resorts, people like to jump on skis. Thats basically all it took, I don't think too much 'outside the box' thinking was involved to be honest. We can thank snowboarding for saving skiing, but everyone knows that already.
I think the last great example of 'breaking the mold' was Robotfood. These guys truly did something that changed the entire direction of a sport. They created a sub culture within snowboarding, the way they presented their ideas had never been done before. This edit is not like that at all, these are all old, tired cliches that we have all seen a million times before. Did they take it up to a new level? For a ski edit, yes. On a broader scale, no. Why do we need MTV, Lil' Wayne influence in skiing? Is it something we are sorely lacking? This is a broad social influence that many young people relate too. FDwear just took it, pushed it one step further and tried to relate it to skiing. Was it necessary? I don't think so. It came off to me as childish and embarrassing.
The thing for me is that I actually view this edit as 'conforming'. Not conforming to the stereotypical skier image, but conforming to a much broader social movement. Are the ideas presented in this edit unique to FDwear? No. Where did FDwear get these ideas from? What makes people in general think that the image portrayed is badass? I think to most people the answer is fairly obvious.
The plane, the cars / drifting, the guns, the money throwing, the club scene....nothing here is breaking the mold, they are merely trying to fit a much broader mold onto the sub-culture of skiing. No doubt rap videos have inspired many of the social ideas we encounter everyday, how is ripping one off 'breaking the mold'?
I don't think the creation of this sport was as much a phenomenon as some people would like to believe. People had skis, snowboard parks were built at ski resorts, people like to jump on skis. Thats basically all it took, I don't think too much 'outside the box' thinking was involved to be honest. We can thank snowboarding for saving skiing, but everyone knows that already.
I think the last great example of 'breaking the mold' was Robotfood. These guys truly did something that changed the entire direction of a sport. They created a sub culture within snowboarding, the way they presented their ideas had never been done before. This edit is not like that at all, these are all old, tired cliches that we have all seen a million times before. Did they take it up to a new level? For a ski edit, yes. On a broader scale, no. Why do we need MTV, Lil' Wayne influence in skiing? Is it something we are sorely lacking? This is a broad social influence that many young people relate too. FDwear just took it, pushed it one step further and tried to relate it to skiing. Was it necessary? I don't think so. It came off to me as childish and embarrassing.