I think I need to add my 2 cents to this thread.
First of all, this is Jeff Neagle, not Erik, posting, so don't freak out and say it's Erik trying to defend himself or something.
I think the most important thing is to clear up is Erik's image. He's not a guido, he's a down to earth guy who grew up skiing Shweitzer, worked in corporate world for a few years, decided it wasn't for him, so he started Boone Skis. It's hard word starting a ski company when you don't have a ton of capital or resources, and Erik has been doing an exceptional job working with what he can afford to get his hands on.
Yes, the skis have had some durability issues, but what start up ski company hasn't? What I think is most important is that Erik does listen (despite popular belief) to his customers and team riders and the skis have been getting consistently better with each production run. The company is committed to making quality skis and supporting people who participate in the sport we love. When a change needs to be made to current ski design or production, it's made. Everyone at Boone is a skier, and we all want to be on the best possible skis as well.
I can't directly comment on this warranty issue because I rarely handle any warranties and didn't see the skis in person, but I will say a couple things. Magic Sticks were some of the early production runs, which historically were not as durable as the current skis. My current 180 freeride skis from Boone have been my every day park/freeride for around 70 days and are in great shape. Some edge cracks, but that's to be expected when you slide rails every day. At the shop I work in I have seen brand new Stocklis come back to the store with cracked sidewalls after a day of use. Crazy things happen, usually those crazy things are a manufacturer defect, but every once in a while it's because they landed on a rock, drove over them, etc. (I'm not inferring that this happened to the OP)
So, to end this, I completely understand where the OP is coming from. It absolutely sucks when something breaks and you think it was a defect, only to find out the company in question disagrees. I'm sure it has happened to all of us. That doesn't mean Boone isn't committed to providing a quality product. I don't remember if you mentioned if you called or not, but I would have tried calling Boone. 9 times out of 10 you'll get Erik, if no one answers leave a message. He wants to help out park skiers, trust me.
To the OP and everyone else with an obvious negative opinion of Boone: I hope that you guys don't just turn your back on the company. Keep an open mind and I think you'll be pleasantly surprised at what Boone has to offer currently and in the future.