Nothing about your responses in this thread, Boone, has made me think any more of you. I do not know if you let interns respond to threads, such as this one, but it seemed that way when I read "Let the haters hate" from one of your comments.
Liam's obviously given your company a chance in buying a pair of your skis, be them new or old. And I find it hard to believe that he has received such a deal because of a "gift" when the skis he bought were 2 or 3 years old (or 4 years old according to when they were manufactured). I too, as owner of a company, would get rid of old stock at a lowered price, even if it only means lowering the financial loss.
The pictures also show no evidence of rail markings, even though they are not the sharpest pictures.
I've known Liam for a few years now and he had been dealing with a lot of ski issues this year because of the skis he purchased off of you. And I do recall the time when he told me that his new Boone skis broke within the first couple of days of not hitting rails. I offered him my old skis but he declined because they were too long for him. He then told me that he would just ride his broken skis until he heard from Boone, which was after he took the pictures of his sidewalls, and that was the last I had heard about all of this until now.
I do not think you have gone about defending your company's name in the proper manner. I stand behind Liam on this.