You've got to consider size of features hit and at least some level of diversity in the riding.
I don't think there is a way either ced of max could win simply based on the rail focused nature of their edits, even if they are revolutionary.
I'm going to have to give my pick to either yan or ben based on the creativity and size of their urban, this fills the Casabon Henrik void to some degree.
Out of the two, I'm going to have to go with Benoit, simply based on his jump game. Level 1 doesn't have as many big booter slayers as they did in the past and I think he fit in nicely.
Just ma 2 cents though, so much talent. L1P really can't go all that wrong here