You are asking opinions on who makes the best boots.  These are all biased because obviously people are going to mention the brand they use, because they fit their feet.  Someone that doesn't fit them is gonna say hell no to their opinions.  The real question is, who makes a boot that fits your feet properly and with the flex you want.  The only way to find this out is to stuff your feet into them and see if they work for you.  Even better if it's with the help of a good bootfitter.
The 2 boots you mentioned are complete opposites in fit.  If you fit one, you won't fit the other.  Hell, odds are that you won't fit either.
In conclusion........your question is impossible for us to answer and get something right for you.