Surely any guy who says that he finds 'inner beauty' is sexy is (a) really unattractive, (b) going out with someone really unattractive or (c) trying to pull... or, of course, it could be genuine, and I'm just being horrible, but I don't know if I'd believe that.
Personally, I'd go for for an athletic guy who likes to have fun, is liked by animals and doesn't take himself or the world too seriously. Tall with happy eyes a definite plus...