I judged the rails in slopestyle. Keep in mind that I saw a total of about, I dunno, 500-600 hundred slopestyle runs over the course of the comp. Both of us on the rail tower absolutely loved Logans pretzels, and without the scoresheet in front of me I can tell you that he was certainly compensated for them. I can also tell you that I clearly remember some of his practice runs as some of the best through the rail section, definitely his own best runs. However, I don't think he quite got them as he wanted in his finals. Barely no one was spinning onto the second rail and it was explicitly discussed by the judges that he would be rewarded for doing so, not to mention a pretzel out.
I can't speak for the rest of the judges, because from where we sat it was impossible to see the rest of the run. So with that said, I can chip in only with my overall opinion on the results.
Decker and Cosco slayed the course all week long and deserved to be up top. But to illustrate the importance of style and impression, please look to Stef Thomas as he did nothign more than 5's and stuck with the nastest tail press I've ever seen on one of his rails. Let it be a lesson to the entire world of Slopestyle/Halfpipe/QP/Rail comps that STYLE is a massive contributor to solid results.
And for the record, it's a bloody shame that Phillipi hurt his ankle, because if I recall correctly he had the highest score out of anyones rail sections all week long. Too bad it wasn't in finals.