Been seeing this thread a lot lately and I was in the same boat. What I can tell you is that it really depends on what your priorities are in college. If you value actual education even a bit, go to U of U hands down. It has way more resources and connections post college than MSU could dream of. I think U of U has better skiing for sure and its a lot closer so less driving unless the canyons are screwed up. Where MSU makes up for it is that it is probably easier to make friends in Bozeman than Utah in general. It is a much smaller school too. What I can say from personal experience is that as an introvert, I actually have had a better time at a larger school, crazy i know. Bozeman might also have a better party scene, but that is debatable. If you are big on sports and school spirit stuff go to U of U. If you have ever wanted to compete, Utah has better options with their freeride team being top notch. I dont know how good u are at skiing but if you havent been skiing since age 2 it can be intimidating in UT. Its like everyone is amazing or they don't ski at all.