Thoughts on Eileen Gu getting a pro model before Kelly Sildaru?

L

Leprechaunonskis

New member
First of all congrats to Eileen Gu for getting her own pro model.

But doesn’t Kelly deserve to have her own ski first as she’s been a member of the faction team for the past 4 years, is the youngest winter xgames gold medalist and only female skier to take home 3 gold’s at one xgames. While Eileen has only been a faction team member for the past year.

Shouldn’t team riders who have invested a lot of time in a company and produced greater results For said company be prioritised for pro model skis?
 
Yeah I completly agree with you. Don't know why Kelly or any other meber for example Mathilde or so didn't got a pro model... I mean Eileen is on the team just one year. Haha so maybe she had to pay an enormous mount of money to faction ;)

**This post was edited on Jul 11th 2020 at 8:55:37am
 
She skis for China in international competitions and the Chinese ski market is expanding super quick, Faction will for sure sell a shitload of these. I also agree that Kelly is more deserving but this makes perfect sense from Faction's standpoint
 
yeah it was kinda weird this older lady that I talk to at hood last week basically knew of two free skiers Candide and Eileen Gu so she is getting some marketing pull with some kids moms out there somehow
 
Yeah it sucks for Kelly but it seems to be a marketing thing, the strength of the Asian market is on of their sales growth drivers. Hopefully Kelly gets hers soon
 
100% for marketing in China.

Also isn't it a bit of a pisser when someone lives their whole life in a country, is given all their opportunities because of the country they're in, take advantage of all the facilities offered in that country, then decide to essentially say fuck you and compete for a different country? Likely she was offered mucho $$ from China. She's a good skier and definitely had a great chance of competing for team US. Not like she's pulling a Swaney and only competing for China because she couldn't make team USA (or Gus.. there's no way he would have made Team USA again).
 
Yea honestly forgot how freeskiing is a very young sport in most places outside Europe, Canada and the US.

14156117:pinkcamo1000 said:
She skis for China in international competitions and the Chinese ski market is expanding super quick, Faction will for sure sell a shitload of these. I also agree that Kelly is more deserving but this makes perfect sense from Faction's standpoint
Click to expand...
 
14156117:pinkcamo1000 said:
She skis for China in international competitions and the Chinese ski market is expanding super quick, Faction will for sure sell a shitload of these. I also agree that Kelly is more deserving but this makes perfect sense from Faction's standpoint
Click to expand...

Hit the nail right on the head. I have a chinese coworker who got into freestyle skiing. Eileen is the person her and rest of china looks up to as the gold standard (even though shes an american by all means lol). This is a great move for faction skis to get into the chinese market. Glad i invested in them

**This post was edited on Jul 11th 2020 at 3:47:10pm
 
Totally makes sense from a business perspective but imagine having to sit down Kelly, Mathilde, and Sarah Hoefflin to break the news that faction is about to stop a women’s pro model that isn’t one of theirs

*drop not stop lol

**This post was edited on Jul 11th 2020 at 8:31:06pm
 
14156171:DesertStix said:
Totally makes sense from a business perspective but imagine having to sit down Kelly, Mathilde, and Sarah Hoefflin to break the news that faction is about to stop a women’s pro model that isn’t one of theirs

*drop not stop lol

**This post was edited on Jul 11th 2020 at 8:31:06pm
Click to expand...

fully agree Mathilde, and Sarah Hoefflin deserve a pro model before any of the other girls on the team
 
Seems like it’s just a prodigy with a different top sheet. Who’s to say the other women on the team don’t have one too and just haven’t released it yet?
 
(or Gus.. there's no way he would have made Team USA again).[/quote]

I'm thinking Gus could probably grab a spot on the US pipe team, he took some W's this year after probably skiing a fraction of the other guys
 
I was gonna say, even Giulias been on faction a while, Sarah Hoefflin won Olympic gold for them so idk Kelly should have a pro model ski for sure by now. Some friends in the upcoming comp scene have made it clear that she’s making fucking dough already cause the whole China deal. Magazine shoots, pro model ski and even on Red Bull at 15 is pretty nuts.
 
14156263:animator said:
Seems like it’s just a prodigy with a different top sheet. Who’s to say the other women on the team don’t have one too and just haven’t released it yet?
Click to expand...

968010.png

Looks like it's 117-83-109, which isn't the size of any of the current prodigy skis tho
 
14156620:OCoffey said:
Do ya live under a rock?
Click to expand...

14156623:armchair_skier said:
I don’t watch women’s comp skiing.
Click to expand...

Huge vibe, it’s literally just the WNBA if snowsports. No dubs/dunks, barely viewed and pulls in hardly any money, if Kelly does ever get a pro mode I’d hope they call it “the 900’s” cause that’s really all she got
 
14156625:Young_patty said:
No dubs/dunks
Click to expand...

i'm not gonna try to tell you that you need to watch and be entertained by women's skiing but this is just really untrue. watch x games big air from this year, they threw some wild shit honestly
 
14156625:Young_patty said:
Huge vibe, it’s literally just the WNBA if snowsports. No dubs/dunks, barely viewed and pulls in hardly any money, if Kelly does ever get a pro mode I’d hope they call it “the 900’s” cause that’s really all she got
Click to expand...

Dude the women are progressing hard. Throwing carving dub 12s and shit. For me it's just as fun to watch cuz I have no clue what's getting thrown down, when I watch men I can call what trick they're gonna do before they drop and be right 75% of the time
 
14156630:SofaKingSick said:
i'm not gonna try to tell you that you need to watch and be entertained by women's skiing but this is just really untrue. watch x games big air from this year, they threw some wild shit honestly
Click to expand...

To be fair I’ve seen a number of woman’s events and I even made it through a 1/3 of Factions chick flick. Imma stop before I dig myself a misogyny hole but at the end of the day why would you want to watch sub par skiing?
 
14156634:Young_patty said:
To be fair I’ve seen a number of woman’s events and I even made it through a 1/3 of Factions chick flick. Imma stop before I dig myself a misogyny hole but at the end of the day why would you want to watch sub par skiing?
Click to expand...

idk man people will get mad hype on some up and comer dude skier putting out a park edit or a chill urban movie with smaller features, but for some reason every woman has to be doing the most insane shit possible to get any recognition.

For example, people will hate on a dude doing dubs in the street because it's "comp style" but then turn around and say that women's skiing is lame because they don't do enough dubs or huge spins. So it seems to me that a lot of the time women's skiing is just held to a different standard. Not necessarily a higher standard, just different. I think the best thing to do is instead of constantly comparing it to men's skiing, just take the skiing for what it is.
 
14156625:Young_patty said:
Huge vibe, it’s literally just the WNBA if snowsports. No dubs/dunks, barely viewed and pulls in hardly any money, if Kelly does ever get a pro mode I’d hope they call it “the 900’s” cause that’s really all she got
Click to expand...

Really all she has is a 900? Can you even switch 10 one way? Cause she can flawlessly do them both ways. And to say there’s no dubs in women’s skiing is also fucking retarded, only thing to criticize kelly for is she isn’t doing doubles like a good amount of girls are, that are on the faction team too.
 
14156638:pinkcamo1000 said:
idk man people will get mad hype on some up and comer dude skier putting out a park edit or a chill urban movie with smaller features, but for some reason every woman has to be doing the most insane shit possible to get any recognition.

For example, people will hate on a dude doing dubs in the street because it's "comp style" but then turn around and say that women's skiing is lame because they don't do enough dubs or huge spins. So it seems to me that a lot of the time women's skiing is just held to a different standard. Not necessarily a higher standard, just different. I think the best thing to do is instead of constantly comparing it to men's skiing, just take the skiing for what it is.
Click to expand...

If you say so dude, it’s all opinion so I’m not gonna heat over it but IMO watching women’s comp skiing just ain’t hype for me, I’d rather watch men’s events because the caliber of skiing is just at a much higher level. Sorry. I’m not saying I won’t tune in for a Taylor Lundquist or Tatum edit cause there are some girls puttin down clips but comp wise I could care less about Kelly Silderu doing the same 900’s she’s done at every X-games or watching small 540’s in a super pipe Event.

14156640:Titus69 said:
only thing to criticize kelly for is she isn’t doing doubles like a good amount of girls are, that are on the faction team too.
Click to expand...

Couldn’t have said it better, that’s why she doesn’t need a faction pro model
 
14156647:Young_patty said:
If you say so dude, it’s all opinion so I’m not gonna heat over it but IMO watching women’s comp skiing just ain’t hype for me, I’d rather watch men’s events because the caliber of skiing is just at a much higher level. Sorry. I’m not saying I won’t tune in for a Taylor Lundquist or Tatum edit cause there are some girls puttin down clips but comp wise I could care less about Kelly Silderu doing the same 900’s she’s done at every X-games or watching small 540’s in a super pipe Event.
Click to expand...

I agree, I do not give a shit about Kelly doing the same 900s we've seen a bunch of times or small 540s in a super pipe. But that's cause I've seen that stuff done by them before, and men's comp skiing is just as repetitive, if not more. I don't watch men's or women's comp skiing because they're both super repetitive and boring, but that's just the way comp skiing has always been.

Basically you're proving my point that men's and women's skiing are held to different standards. It's ok for men to do the same canned triple every run, but if Kelly Sildaru does too many 900s it means all women's comp events are wack.
 
14156647:Young_patty said:
If you say so dude, it’s all opinion so I’m not gonna heat over it but IMO watching women’s comp skiing just ain’t hype for me, I’d rather watch men’s events because the caliber of skiing is just at a much higher level. Sorry. I’m not saying I won’t tune in for a Taylor Lundquist or Tatum edit cause there are some girls puttin down clips but comp wise I could care less about Kelly Silderu doing the same 900’s she’s done at every X-games or watching small 540’s in a super pipe Event.

Couldn’t have said it better, that’s why she doesn’t need a faction pro model
Click to expand...

Yeah but she’s also been pushing her skiing hard since she was 7, basically one of the faces of women’s free skiing IMO, so many girl pros older than her have been seen showing so much respect for her at comps instead of being mad a girl 6 years younger kicked their ass without a double in her run (cause she can actually ski rails). Not defending her saying she absolutely needs a pro model but it’s funny that she’s done so much for girls skiing and has been on faction for years then suddenly this young hotshot with maybe half of the accolades Kelly’s has who’s already cashing out from her China deal deserves one not long after signing to faction.
 
14156652:pinkcamo1000 said:
I agree, I do not give a shit about Kelly doing the same 900s we've seen a bunch of times or small 540s in a super pipe. But that's cause I've seen that stuff done by them before, and men's comp skiing is just as repetitive, if not more. I don't watch men's or women's comp skiing because they're both super repetitive and boring, but that's just the way comp skiing has always been.

Basically you're proving my point that men's and women's skiing are held to different standards. It's ok for men to do the same canned triple every run, but if Kelly Sildaru does too many 900s it means all women's comp events are wack.
Click to expand...

Comp skiing has definitely been a drag to watch in the past but with all the new formats (few tour mixed format and X-games knuckle Huck to name a couple) have been making me tune back in, -games Norway men’s knuckle Huck was actually super fun to watch and the roster was a refreshing mix of skiers. Also you’re dancing around the ball, “different standards” just means “we hold women skiers to lower standards” because yes a canned triple is just as boring to watch as stock 900’s but objectively speaking that canned triple is on a muuuuch higher level of skiing.

14156653:Titus69 said:
Yeah but she’s also been pushing her skiing hard since she was 7, basically one of the faces of women’s free skiing IMO, so many girl pros older than her have been seen showing so much respect for her at comps instead of being mad a girl 6 years younger kicked their ass without a double in her run (cause she can actually ski rails). Not defending her saying she absolutely needs a pro model but it’s funny that she’s done so much for girls skiing and has been on faction for years then suddenly this young hotshot with maybe half of the accolades Kelly’s has who’s already cashing out from her China deal deserves one not long after signing to faction.
Click to expand...

I agree with you her rail game is better than many of her competitors (but I’m a bit out of the women’s comp scene so I could be wrong) but honestly I think faction did it just because she’s a better skier, she might be newer to the scene and have only half the accolades as Kelly but you said it yourself she just shreds harder and will probably make it easier for faction to sell her pro models and make money, which is the goal of every ski company. Kelly definitely has a huge image and reputation in the women’s comp scene but faction might be looking at just skill sets to deciding who will sell more skis for them over time.
 
14156655:Young_patty said:
Comp skiing has definitely been a drag to watch in the past but with all the new formats (few tour mixed format and X-games knuckle Huck to name a couple) have been making me tune back in, -games Norway men’s knuckle Huck was actually super fun to watch and the roster was a refreshing mix of skiers. Also you’re dancing around the ball, “different standards” just means “we hold women skiers to lower standards” because yes a canned triple is just as boring to watch as stock 900’s but objectively speaking that canned triple is on a muuuuch higher level of skiing.

I agree with you her rail game is better than many of her competitors (but I’m a bit out of the women’s comp scene so I could be wrong) but honestly I think faction did it just because she’s a better skier, she might be newer to the scene and have only half the accolades as Kelly but you said it yourself she just shreds harder and will probably make it easier for faction to sell her pro models and make money, which is the goal of every ski company. Kelly definitely has a huge image and reputation in the women’s comp scene but faction might be looking at just skill sets to deciding who will sell more skis for them over time.
Click to expand...

Yeah I think we’re both right or onto something with it, obviously I feel kelly maybe should have a pro model since she’s a very decorated athlete who’s been going on about 10 years of big exposure, Eileen is younger and brand new to faction but yeah I do think she will be something big in women’s skiing which might be their idea. She just doesn’t have the legacy that girls like kelly have, people in skiing have no clue who Eileen is and I don’t think she’s done anything out of the ordinary except be 15 and pretty good. Funny thought, when the olympics come around and she’s repping China with her pro model factions, sales over there are gonna boom cause she’s already a celebrity.
 
14156658:Titus69 said:
I don’t think she’s done anything out of the ordinary except be 15 and pretty good. Funny thought, when the olympics come around and she’s repping China with her pro model factions, sales over there are gonna boom cause she’s already a celebrity.
Click to expand...

Oh shit, dude they put her on cause she was young and good but that’s more or less the same reason they put Silderu on. You’re definitely right too about her posting up at the olympics with her faction pro models too, the exposure would be huge for faction and it would probably let em dip into the Chinese ski market even more. I think they’re definitely tryna crank out a Silderu 2.0 for sure
 
14156659:Young_patty said:
Oh shit, dude they put her on cause she was young and good but that’s more or less the same reason they put Silderu on. You’re definitely right too about her posting up at the olympics with her faction pro models too, the exposure would be huge for faction and it would probably let em dip into the Chinese ski market even more. I think they’re definitely tryna crank out a Silderu 2.0 for sure
Click to expand...

Finally someone gets it. The reason ski brands pay people to use their skis is because it’s advertising. “Pro models” are just an extension of this idea.
 
14156662:armchair_skier said:
Finally someone gets it. The reason ski brands pay people to use their skis is because it’s advertising. “Pro models” are just an extension of this idea.
Click to expand...

And sometimes the athlete of said pro model could and usually should get a profit off the sales of the ski, that’s gotta be part of it though cause I’m pretty sure to that country she’s a big shot or a prodigy or whatever. If there’s one thing I can see happening its she does well in future comps/olympics in China and boom all the girl skiers especially in Asia will wanna be what she’s on. Lol marketing.
 
14156655:Young_patty said:
Comp skiing has definitely been a drag to watch in the past but with all the new formats (few tour mixed format and X-games knuckle Huck to name a couple) have been making me tune back in, -games Norway men’s knuckle Huck was actually super fun to watch and the roster was a refreshing mix of skiers. Also you’re dancing around the ball, “different standards” just means “we hold women skiers to lower standards” because yes a canned triple is just as boring to watch as stock 900’s but objectively speaking that canned triple is on a muuuuch higher level of skiing.
Click to expand...

did they even have knuckle huck for the ladies? And yes, in competition skiing women are generally held to a lower standard. But I think that in some ways in other areas of skiing women are actually held to a higher standard. Like in my example before, a dude can put out a chill edit with low consequence features/tricks and people will be like "so chill, very relatable" etc. Whereas when girls put out content it's always "I COULD DO THESE TRICKS SHE'S NOT EVEN GOOD, I WILL GET A SEX CHANGE SO I CAN BE SPONSORED TOO LMAO XD" In one instance the lower consequence skiing is just appreciated for what it is, whereas in the other it's just compared to men's skiing. See what I'm saying?
 
Women are starting to go upside down more some throwing dubs. Idk I feel like you have to be able to dip that axis a bit these days.
 
oh even tho Eileen kills it, let's be real here, she's basically the most marketable athlete to rhe Chinese people ever, so it would make sense for her to have a ski, now that china is expanding their ski industry much more. I don't really think this very much to do with skill.
 
14156704:pinkcamo1000 said:
did they even have knuckle huck for the ladies? And yes, in competition skiing women are generally held to a lower standard. But I think that in some ways in other areas of skiing women are actually held to a higher standard. Like in my example before, a dude can put out a chill edit with low consequence features/tricks and people will be like "so chill, very relatable" etc. Whereas when girls put out content it's always "I COULD DO THESE TRICKS SHE'S NOT EVEN GOOD, I WILL GET A SEX CHANGE SO I CAN BE SPONSORED TOO LMAO XD" In one instance the lower consequence skiing is just appreciated for what it is, whereas in the other it's just compared to men's skiing. See what I'm saying?
Click to expand...

Honestly, I doubt most people would tune in for women’s Kunckle huck and I doubt many even tuned in for men’s so no shocker that there isn’t one. Kinda grasping for straws saying dudes who put out shit edits still get applauded, most men that suck aren’t putting out pro parts (except Vishnu obviously) so comparing them to pro women segments is once again simply holding them to lower standards. The standard are clearly just lower comp scene or not no matter what way you want to spin it and that’s why there Isn’t as much interest in it I’d imagine.
 
14156911:Young_patty said:
Honestly, I doubt most people would tune in for women’s Kunckle huck and I doubt many even tuned in for men’s so no shocker that there isn’t one. Kinda grasping for straws saying dudes who put out shit edits still get applauded, most men that suck aren’t putting out pro parts (except Vishnu obviously) so comparing them to pro women segments is once again simply holding them to lower standards. The standard are clearly just lower comp scene or not no matter what way you want to spin it and that’s why there Isn’t as much interest in it I’d imagine.
Click to expand...

You clearly did not watch the knuckle huck highlights if you’re saying people wouldn’t tune in for it.

Watch jyosei and you’ll realise that despite being at a lower overall standard than men’s skiing, women’s skiing is still great to watch. https://www.newschoolers.com/videos/watch/946242/JYOSEI
 
This is kinda off topic, but the other day I realized...

Taylor Lundquist - skates better than me, skis (much) better than me, has cooler tattoos than I do, parties harder, and gets hotter chicks than I do...

She is basically my own ideal version of myself...
 
Okay but since we are on the topic of faction pro models, why doesn't Alex Hall have one yet?

Edit for spelling

**This post was edited on Jul 16th 2020 at 12:16:34pm
 
14157080:SoggyOatmeal420 said:
Okay but since we are on the topic of faction pro models, why does Alex Hall have one yet
Click to expand...

Arent the candides the only one for faction besides eileens? I think overall it’s just kinda funny, I mean she’s nasty and good enough to deserve one but I’d be pretty salty if I won the olympic slope for faction and the new girl on the team gets a pro model instantly. But obviously there’s more than skills and results to it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top