Oni on 900S is good.  I think I'm getting my other sleeve and possibly chest piece by either Greg and/or Sarah there, and I live half a block away so I can walk, which is always a plus.
Nate and Dean at Lost Art on State are good.  They both have done a lot of work on some friends.
Everybody at Eleventh St. in Sugarhouse is good.  Jake does awesome script, Gailan has awesome color work, and every one else is overall good.
As for Vic at Goodtimes, a close friend of mine had her sleeve done by him and it looks nice.  But, she did say he was really expensive and really slow.
Truthfully, it's all about personal preference so go check out portfolios and see for yourself.