Surface one life vs moment pb&j

I am looking to get a new pair of skis this year and I have narrowed my search down to these two skis. I want something to serve as a 1 ski quiver that will have a playfull no-catch feel in the park and agility in the trees and powder in general. I like to jib around and do inverted tricks in the park (mistys, backies, rodeos) but don't care too much about spinning, so weight is an issue but swing weight not so much. I am 6'5" and weigh 230 and i would probably want the 189 surface and the 188 pb&j. My heavy weight has made me choose these both rather stiff skis, and I want a ski that will be able to give me alot of stability on landings. what do people think i should get?

 
I'm 6'3 200 and went with the PB&J's 188 last season. My favorite ski to date and I've been through many. Matter of fact at the end of the season I picked up pair of Jaguar Sharks 192 I was so impressed. I wish I could give you a comparison, but I've never been on Surface skis. Good Luck with your decision.
 
i own both skis actually in the same lengths. I'm 6'3'' and 190. I've actually skied the one lifes in the park more (i've had them for longer) and they're surprisingly fun, especially on really soft days when you can plow through ruts and such on landings with the width and rocker. mine are -1 from center and they're still pretty weird (terrifying might be a better word) to ski switch...especially coming in to jumps and stuff. they're definitely fun but i wouldn't want them as my only park ski.

i have skied a good amount of normal east coast conditions park on my pb&j's and they're pretty solid for that. they're pretty stiff, stable, and not that playful, but will provide a lot more support on jumps and such. haven't skied them in slushy park but i'd imagine they'd be the best of both worlds- can carve way better than the one lifes (especially switch) but still float in slush.

so basically the one lifes are gonna be more playful and the pbnj's will be a lot more stable and better for carving...probably what you already knew, but hopefully that helps. heres an edit from when i was using the one lifes a lot in the park -

 
depends what the conditions are but considering its essentially a snowblade (100 cm running length), they're pretty stable. its because they cambered portion of the ski is like race ski stiff. i've skied bentchentlers and double helixes and they're wayy more stable than those....bentchentlers i could essentially lean back a little bit and fall over. if its like perfectly groomed park, you have to be pretty on point on landings, but softer snow or spring park conditions they're not bad at all.
 
My 189 one lifes are fun to fool around on, but they are super clumsy. I have the 10's and they have camber underfoot, which is retarded. Pretty sure every year after that they are just flat. Stiffest ski I have ever been on, it's like race ski stiff. I would choose the PB&J's, almost bought them as my park ski.
 
I only disagree with one thing. I feel like the PB&J's are very playful. They are pretty poppy and feel lively to me.
 
one lifes are awesome, definitely a super playful ski, which says a lot coming from me because i typically hate stiff skis, and these things are really f-ing stiff. but somehow their huge rocker makes them feel like a medium flexing, poppy, surfey ski. on hardpack the camber underfoot definitely makes them feel weird, (this is the one thing i dont like about them, they should have just kept it flat underfoot, i feel like they'd carve better and feel a lot more natural, im pretty sure this years are flat underfoot fyi)anyway, once you get used to how you have to ski these things, they are f-ing amazing, you can still carve GS type turns on them and they actually carve pretty damn well on hardpack, but where they really get fun is when you ski them in a more slashy kind of way, especially when it gets chopped or powder. like build up speed and whip them sideways, with the aggressive rocker and stiffness, you can literally lean back and lean on that big rocker tail and ride out a big old sidedways slash on your tails, super fun over knuckles and rollers. they nose butter pretty well too, you can lean as hard as you want on the noses knowing its gonna be there, and the big rocker makes it easy to commit and actually butter them.

in powder the 179 feels a tad short, i think a 185 would be better, but regardless, they dont sink, float really well, you can ski them like a normal ski, and you can ski them like i said before, build up a bunch of speed and really slash the crap out of them. the harder you ski the better they feel. you cant push them enough almost.
 
Back
Top