dub post but just re-watched every finalist edit and heres my take imo:
-Siggers went huge and made a quality edit but the only way i see him having a chance of winning is if carinthia somehow makes their setup as backcountry orientated as snoqualmie made it last year.
-Ben Smith is getting no credit and had arguably the most technical tricks with style.
-Jonah Williams used his left over footage, but he's just really fricking good
-Gabe does have that weird and generic arm swing, but his creativity and hand drags were insane. I think he will fit right in with level 1, although there were no urban shots
-Alec Nelson... i watched his edit a few times. by far my favorite, 4 on shift blind 2 couldn't have been cleaner. Plus those tricks he put in on that backcountry (hood??) kicker were really dope.
-Wagstrom got through to finals with his lsm style. Solid edit but i feel like a few semi finalists could have easily took his spot.
-Kazakov had a good mix of urban and backcountry but he didn't bring anything special to the table.
Swadburg's style was really nice, i enjoyed his edit. Im not sure if he has too great of a chance of winning, but anything could happen.
-Geoff put out one of the best urban edits I've ever seen. That edit could hold its own in a level 1 film. I think he has one of the better chances.
in conclusion, there was no edit that could stand up to brower's edit last year, but i think the field is stacked throughout this year