Star Wars Rogue One
- Thread starter .MASSHOLE.
- Start date
MicroMix
Member
Enjoyed the film, but the first half of the movie, pretty much everything pre-Scarif attack, was pretty weak. Its way too busy with too many irrelevant characters and locations. Everything that involved Forest Whitaker made it feel reminiscent of episodes 1-3, which isn't exactly a good thing.
Honestly though, the Darth Vader scene makes the entire movie worth it.
Honestly though, the Darth Vader scene makes the entire movie worth it.
Zimmy
Active member
13766637:Campeador said:
Would be ironic if they called in Lucas in to do 7-9 as he had envisaged. I think the trouble they have with him is that he's so hands-on that they had to sideline him for 7. Hard to find a comfortable gray area with that guy. Perhaps with his ~$4 billion he could buy the rights back at some point.
Campeador
Active member
13766815:saskskier said:
Not when the main writer has a specific agenda, and so does Disney. It's only going to get worse.
The real question is, with one of these movies coming out every year for a while, when will you get sick of them?
"Tie fighter! X-Wings! Light sabers!"
So boring, and such an obvious, cynical cash grab. Wonder bread Star Wars.
At least George Lucas had the decency to space his movies out by three years.
S.J.W
Active member
13766887:Campeador said:
You sound like those idiots who blew their shit over American Sniper being a sad depiction of American imperialism and how could Hollywood ever justify that. Just fucking get over it. It's a fucking movie. No one is forcing anyone to go see the movie. For someone who hates Bernie Sanders, you sure do hate capitlism as well. People want star wars and Disney is providing Star Wars. Basic supply and demand. And people probably won't get over Star Wars, I've watched all seven films more times than I can count, the clones wars TV shows, rebels and the EU. Just face it, your bitter old bitch of a man can't handle anything remotely out of the cliche white male protagonist. Did you hate Gran Torino? Despite that clearly being a racist movie. But guess what IT'S JUST A FUCKING MOVIE
willysworld
Active member
13766656:Campeador said:
You suck ...
rogue one was amazing !!!
willysworld
Active member
13766656:Campeador said:
You suck ...
rogue one was amazing !!!
Young_patty
Active member
I enjoyed Rogue one. I thought it did a nice job of filling in the story before A New Hope and just had a good story in general especially the whole "Rebels running around pew-pewing Storm Troopers" approach like It had more of a war movie feel to it . Plus the battle scenes were totally rad from the Taliban-y street fight on Jedha to the epic final battles above and on Scarif.
Zimmy
Active member
Just read the plot synopsis. Now I can go see it and not have to worry about losing the plot.. (it doesn't look too complex) .. it has a lot of elements from previous SW (even Force Awakens) like the force field around planet (RoJ)... and reminds me a bit of Terminator 2 and Titanic as well. Can't anyone be original anymore?
TheDoughAbides
Active member
lol cuckpeador = regurgitated bullshit from the manosphere
go cry about being emasculated by modern society somewhere else, cromagnan
go cry about being emasculated by modern society somewhere else, cromagnan
K-Dot.
Active member
13768244:Campeador said:
There are plenty of safe spaces in this country but most of them involve being white, not reading news involving critical though and having sex with your step sister. But you already know all about that.
Also it's funny that you consider star wars to be a social justice movie. It never claimed to be anything more than a made up Scifi story with action and adventure. You read into it to be socially aware and ended up getting triggered. It's kind of sad how you think yourself into being scared of the world. Also, don't take it out on Disney just because it's no longer antisemitic
TheDoughAbides
Active member
13768244:Campeador said:
lol cuckpeador thinks january 20th will be the day that everything changes for him! wishful thinking cuckpeador! even the donald cant fix lead poisoning!
TheHamburglar
Active member
Damn, cuckboy gettin flamed hard in this thread too, nice
Zimmy
Active member
Right at the end, after Jyn broadcasts the plans through the tower, they are picked up by the rebel mothership (you see Admiral Ackbar really excited as he sees the data being downloard) but then you see guys on that ship putting it on a disk a handing it off too each other (as Vader is killing them) and then eventually through a door where Leia gets it and leaves on the smaller cargo ship. Is that right? So Vader actually boarded the rebel mothership to obtain the plans? If the mothership had the plans, why did they need to go to such an effort to put it on the disk? (it was stored on the motherships drive's and they could've just warp-drived out) Or were they worried that mothership would be destroyed? Also, wouldn't have multiple parties got the plans, as Jyn talks about it being broadcast to the entire universe on the tower?
And then when A New Hope starts, you see an imperial cruiser catching up to that same cargo ship, so that is meant to happen only a few minutes later? Why didn't the cargo ship warp-drive away as soon as it had the plans? So where did the mothership go, and where did the cruiser come from?
Also, the last scene with Vader wasn't anything special, it didn't last long either and he's just killing people as he's walking forward in the corridor. It was much more brutal at the end of Revenge of the Sith when he went beserk on the Jedi toddlers and the people that helped him. Also, when you see him in R1 taking a bath in goo, you barely see him. Maybe I missed something. (or the version shown in Israel is different)
And then when A New Hope starts, you see an imperial cruiser catching up to that same cargo ship, so that is meant to happen only a few minutes later? Why didn't the cargo ship warp-drive away as soon as it had the plans? So where did the mothership go, and where did the cruiser come from?
Also, the last scene with Vader wasn't anything special, it didn't last long either and he's just killing people as he's walking forward in the corridor. It was much more brutal at the end of Revenge of the Sith when he went beserk on the Jedi toddlers and the people that helped him. Also, when you see him in R1 taking a bath in goo, you barely see him. Maybe I missed something. (or the version shown in Israel is different)
Zimmy
Active member
13769022:Paddle_Carve said:
Also, it wasn't really that new either: the security camera footage in ANH already showed him doing that.
I can see why Lucas liked R1: it had the retro vibe of ANH and a lot of the sets and costumes recreated. That was cool. The old x-wing pilots looked out of place, though.
On 7-9, I would've preferred to see Lucas outline the story to Disney and Disney have all their people recreate to that vision on 7-9. Instead they just had their people invent something completely new. Lucas should've done that on 1-3 (possibly harder to do though.) But I think the real failure of Disney is not being able to establish a good working relationship with Lucas (and vice versa.) Too many people vying for power.
The pun on
ronders_
Member
SPOILERS
I thought the movie was alright, really tries to milk the nostalgia factor for all its worth though. Also why do all the deaths have to be so clean and dramatic for the main characters? I think it would be far more shocking and realistic if a character was just running along and got blown apart unexpectedly. Oh and the storm troopers still can't hit the main characters. I loved the reactions of certain family members, though. FIRST THING they said was how it was sexist that none of the rebels that volunteered to go to Scarif were female. haha. feminism.
Pros imo: integration into episode 3, shows effects on civilians and how there's fighting among the rebel alliance, good cg, sad and dark.
cons: messy, hard to keep track of at the beginning, took halfway through the movie to figure out what was going on, trying for nostalgia too hard.
Just my opinions. I'm not a movie critic
I thought the movie was alright, really tries to milk the nostalgia factor for all its worth though. Also why do all the deaths have to be so clean and dramatic for the main characters? I think it would be far more shocking and realistic if a character was just running along and got blown apart unexpectedly. Oh and the storm troopers still can't hit the main characters. I loved the reactions of certain family members, though. FIRST THING they said was how it was sexist that none of the rebels that volunteered to go to Scarif were female. haha. feminism.
Pros imo: integration into episode 3, shows effects on civilians and how there's fighting among the rebel alliance, good cg, sad and dark.
cons: messy, hard to keep track of at the beginning, took halfway through the movie to figure out what was going on, trying for nostalgia too hard.
Just my opinions. I'm not a movie critic
TheHamburglar
Active member
Saw it today, the day Carrie Fisher died. May the Force be with you.
Rogue One, to me, felt like Star Wars-themed Disney ride more than a Star Wars movie. The original trilogy is practically religious to me, the prequels were bad enough, albeit somewhat saved by several things like the music, podracing, good stories, and solid acting from most except Anakin.
This movie felt overacted and poorly written, and didn't evoke the emotional response that I except from a SW movie. Even Force Awakens was better in that aspect. Like an above poster said, it felt like they tried to milk the nostalgia factor for all it was worth.
The fact that John Williams didn't score was glaringly obvious and the movie fell very short musically. He is one of my biggest musical inspirations and a huge reason I fell so in love with SW.
Can someone explain how accurate the movie was in regards to the EU?
This movie was unnecessary and did not need to be made in regards to the storyline. Saturating the Star Wars universe with more decent-at-best movies is sacrilegious to me, and I despise Disney for doing so. Lucas has clearly gone off his meds and should never have sold the rights to Di$ney.
Finally- spoiler alert- NO Bothans died to bring us this information.
Rogue One, to me, felt like Star Wars-themed Disney ride more than a Star Wars movie. The original trilogy is practically religious to me, the prequels were bad enough, albeit somewhat saved by several things like the music, podracing, good stories, and solid acting from most except Anakin.
This movie felt overacted and poorly written, and didn't evoke the emotional response that I except from a SW movie. Even Force Awakens was better in that aspect. Like an above poster said, it felt like they tried to milk the nostalgia factor for all it was worth.
The fact that John Williams didn't score was glaringly obvious and the movie fell very short musically. He is one of my biggest musical inspirations and a huge reason I fell so in love with SW.
Can someone explain how accurate the movie was in regards to the EU?
This movie was unnecessary and did not need to be made in regards to the storyline. Saturating the Star Wars universe with more decent-at-best movies is sacrilegious to me, and I despise Disney for doing so. Lucas has clearly gone off his meds and should never have sold the rights to Di$ney.
Finally- spoiler alert- NO Bothans died to bring us this information.
Bodhisattva_
Active member
13766500:Campeador said:
"Only gay people watched it"
"Nostalgia sells"
Which one is it bud
Bodhisattva_
Active member
13769871:Campeador said:
I was paraphrasing you avoiding the question small dicked asshole god you are such a condescending point avoiding little cocksucker
Bodhisattva_
Active member
13769944:Campeador said:
Legitimately do not remember posting that hahahha my bad
Unpopular opinion incoming...
I was not a fan of rogue one. Unfortunately I think we are beginning to see the path that we all knew Disney was going to take. The money milking route.
The editing and cinematography was choppy and had a lot of empty space. The movie did not feel smooth or really tied together at all. It was like watching one of those old college football games where they cut out all the commercials and replays.
The references and Easter eggs in the film were in your face. They didn't hide little hints here and there in the movie. They literally shouted the references. Just to make sure that you know it's a star wars movie.
There was no character development at all. We go from Jin being rescued as a child to her being in prison as an adult. We don't know why she hates the rebilion and halfway through the movie she flips sides for the sake of the plot. Her partners had no real reason to join her, accept for that they were captured together. And we know nothing about any of them. All of this is a real issue when you kill all the characters off. The audience doesn't care and doesn't feel any emotional connection to anyone besides the robot and the blind monk.
The movie couldn't go ten minutes without some sort of deus ex machina. All in all would not see again. The only redeeming part of the movie was how the got leia down to a t.
I was not a fan of rogue one. Unfortunately I think we are beginning to see the path that we all knew Disney was going to take. The money milking route.
The editing and cinematography was choppy and had a lot of empty space. The movie did not feel smooth or really tied together at all. It was like watching one of those old college football games where they cut out all the commercials and replays.
The references and Easter eggs in the film were in your face. They didn't hide little hints here and there in the movie. They literally shouted the references. Just to make sure that you know it's a star wars movie.
There was no character development at all. We go from Jin being rescued as a child to her being in prison as an adult. We don't know why she hates the rebilion and halfway through the movie she flips sides for the sake of the plot. Her partners had no real reason to join her, accept for that they were captured together. And we know nothing about any of them. All of this is a real issue when you kill all the characters off. The audience doesn't care and doesn't feel any emotional connection to anyone besides the robot and the blind monk.
The movie couldn't go ten minutes without some sort of deus ex machina. All in all would not see again. The only redeeming part of the movie was how the got leia down to a t.
TheHamburglar
Active member
13770274:Lonely said:
You think so? I thought she was very poorly done compared to tarkin
Completely agree with everything else
Zimmy
Active member
13770329:TheHamburglar said:
Interesting vid on how Leia and Tarkin were done in R1 with CGI. Fortunately, they found a head mould of Peter Cushing ('13-'94) from 1984 (3:52) to use for the recreation. I wonder if they can do something similar with Fisher (RIP) for EP9.. did they get a mould before she was buried.
I agree - for the short time I saw young Leia again, I thought I was watching anime.
A few more points while I'm on it.. all the characters didn't need individuals deaths - they all would've died anyway in the final fireball. The camera could've just flashed around the base at that moment of explosion just after Jyn. In fact, I think that would've been more dramatic anyway. Also, there could've even been a gay-type scene with the blind guy and his pal (Chirrut and Baze) -- not that that interests me at all - just to make it in line with the times (the actual director even said he was open for that discussion to take place of a romance between them.) Also the way Jyn ends up on the beach with Cassian just moments after they were on the tower together really killed it for me... did I miss something? That was impossible.
skierman
Active member
13770274:Lonely said:
You're a fucking idiot, that's why. If you re-watch any of the original movies there is hardly any character development throughout a single movie, they don't reveal every secret of a character's past, only hints it, and if you can't reason her choices throughout the movie then you're a retard. I'm sorry if that's offensive but her character was possibly the most basic of human you can get... just like the original movies.
Guess what? The original Star Wars movie took place halfway through a story line so there was no establishing the characters with the audience. Want to know why? Its because the audience didn't need to know how a character jerked off in their bedroom in order to feel involved in the story. Go read a TIME magazine or anything of importance before you make another post making you sound like a fucking idiot.