Totally respectable. I agree that it was far from my favorite shred flick in terms of "personality" or vibe, or whatever those other intangibles are that add depth or spin to shred porn.
Sort of like how I approach music and flicks, I don't hold all snow movies to the same criteria. I enjoy all sorts of movies and songs for VERY different reasons. The part of me that enjoyed Avatar in 3D in IMAX isn't the same part of me that loves Wes Anderson movies. Similarly, the part of me that loved The Art of Flight isn't the same part of me that loves Nipwitz, TC, or Weight.
At the end of the day, no movie can be everything to everyone, but in terms of pure spectacle, level of riding, and level of presentation (heli shots, fancy cams, crazy MEGAMO, graphics/titles, wildlife/mountain pans), I don't know that it gets much better than The Art of Flight. Basically, AOF was exactly what I needed it to be, and I'll turn to Shoot the Moon, or Think Thank's flick for vibe and feel