Evan. Some of your points are right but the same can be applied to park. the freeze thaw cycle applies equally to park, esp jumps, as it does to pipe. That is overcome by good maintenance which has typically not been a Roundtop strong suit.As for them keeping above water, well, read up an monopolies and then you see very clearly why they can do the bare minimum year after year and survive. Finally, ask yourself this: if, as you imply, pipes are not right for mid-atlanitc areas, then why have so many invested heavily in them over the offseason?