ive heard they awesome. scott is super solid, i tried the p4's once and they were super light for scuh a fat ski. plus i think the p3's are really cheap.
negative, i took a cab 5 uber deep on a 10 ft jump, but i dont think it was the skis fault, the sidewall on my ski was cracked so that may have had somethin to do with it, generally quality ski, id recommend them.
williams, they probably had a defect, although that dosnt explain the warranty issues, its still probably the case as long as something else was wrong.