if you land both the same way (sloppy or clean), then it really comes down to the grab you do with it. So like a rodeo 5 with a japan grab compared to a cork 7 with a tail grab, and if the judges know their stuff, then they would know that they are still pretty equal tricks, but change that cork 7 tail to a cork 7 stalefish and the cork 7 should beat the rodeo 5 japan no matter how they land.