"Reflections on Columbus Day"

Zimmerman

Active member
I know it's a little late, but here you go. I like this.

I love Columbus Day. Each year, I recall the simple song I learned as

a child about the man who "discovered" America. I still recall the

innocent boy whose imagination was taken by the story of adventure and

discovery.

In fourteen hundred and ninety two

Columbus sailed the ocean blue.

On Columbus Day, I reflect on the facts of that fateful discovery.

Hispaniola at the time of Columbus' arrival was home to as many as

300,000 people. On seeing the Arawak people Columbus wrote in his

journal, "At daybreak great multitudes of men came to the shore, all

young and of fine shapes, and very handsome. Their eyes are large and

very beautiful." In the same entry he wrote, "It appears to me, that the

people are ingenious, and would be good servants and I am of opinion

that they would very readily become Christians, as they appear to have

no religion." Columbus kidnapped up to 25 people, although only seven or

eight survived the journey back to Spain. By 1496, it is estimated that

one third of the population had been killed or taken as slaves. In

1592, fewer than 200 Indigenous people remained. By 1555, none survived.

I realize every lie and distortion I hold of my country began in that classroom all those years ago.

I love Columbus Day. It reminds me that often, even the most

God-fearing individuals are the most self-deluded. In the spring of

1493, Columbus wrote to a sponsor, "They are artless and generous with

what they have, to such a degree as no one would believe but him who had

seen it. Of anything they have, if it be asked for, they never say no,

but do rather invite the person to accept it, and show as much

lovingness as though they would give their hearts." Later in the letter

Columbus went on to say, "Their Highnesses may see that I shall give

them as much gold as they need ... and slaves as many as they shall

order to be shipped." Though he was aware of their generosity and

selflessness, rather than emulate them, he decided he would subjugate

them. Columbus was the first slave trader in the Americas.

Columbus Day reminds me that my country's origin was based on

violence, subjugation, racism and genocide. As the native population was

decimated, it was deemed necessary to bring slaves from Africa to the

"New World" for cheap, disposable labor. Throughout the years when

America was a slave republic, the wealthiest Americans were those who

owned the most human beings. But we should not forget that slave owners

spanned all classes. This, from America, the country founded on the idea

that all human beings have equal intrinsic worth, value, and rights.

The "land of the free, home of the brave," indeed.

I love Columbus Day. It reminds me that greed corrupts utterly.

Columbus returned to Hispaniola to colonize the island. By 1495 Columbus

and his men were terrorizing the indigenous people, demanding that they

mine for gold and pay tribute to their masters. Those who could not

provide the quota faced dismemberment and were sent back to their people

as an example. There are first-hand accounts of soldiers hunting the

Arawak for sport and feeding people to their dogs. Columbus himself

documented sexual slavery of young children during his reign as

"governor".

Today in America, one in every four African-American men is likely to

be imprisoned. In the "War on Drugs', black and Latino men are

arrested, prosecuted and imprisoned at highly disproportionate rates

than whites. Our prisons are privatized for profit, operations whose

stocks are traded on Wall Street. Whether you are a black man or woman

in one of America's prisons, or you are undocumented and work under the

blazing sun on American farms, you are paid pennies as others enrich

themselves off of your labor.

Foreclosures have separated millions of black and brown Americans

from their property. Of the nearly 10 million people whose homes have

been foreclosed, 40 percent are black and Latino. The net worth in

communities of color has plunged to the lowest level on record. Black

and brown wealth has been transferred to America's largest banks. This

theft has gone unchallenged as the banks have enriched themselves,

received federal bailouts, and now investment companies seek to rent out

the homes to the very people they have been stolen from.

In 1868, the United States signed a treaty setting aside the Black

Hills "for the absolute and undisturbed use and occupancy of the Sioux."

Within years gold was discovered there, and after negotiations to

purchase the land broke down, the United States simply took it. In 1975,

the presiding judge of the United States Court of Claims wrote, "A more

ripe and rank case of dishonorable dealing will never, in all

probability, be found in our history." This "rank case of dishonorable

dealing" did not result in a return of that which was stolen. The Lakota

Nation is currently raising 9 million dollars in order to buy back a

small portion of sacred land in the Black Hills.

I love Columbus Day because the veneration of this man makes clear

how George Bush a self described "compassionate conservative" can

torture people and have a library built in his name. Barack Obama can

win the Nobel Peace Prize as he authorizes summary execution of people

through drone warfare and authorizes indefinite detention without trial

of American citizens. Madeleine Albright, when confronted with the

deaths of up to 500,000 Iraqi children during sanctions, can declare:

"We think the price is worth it." She is now an author and a sought

after speaker on the lecture circuit where she describes her life as

"devoted to human rights." This self-delusion and ideas of grandeur

poison us as we impose the same tough sanctions on Iran and call for

that nations people to be brought to their knees. Medicines dwindle in

Iranian hospitals and prices skyrocket due to hyperinflation, the

currency losing 15 percent of its value overnight. It is only a matter

of time until children starve.

We can look to Afghanistan and Iraq to see our imperialist footprint

spreading across the globe. Afghanistan, with its untapped mineral

wealth estimated in the trillions of dollars, and Iraq with its vast oil

fields, its people only considered "collateral damage" if they are

considered at all. Meanwhile, we formulate agreements with the

governments we impose that will allow our corporations to steal the

resources and keep the citizens in penury. The footprint is on the neck

of the people.

And what of Palestine, and her people? It is America that provides

the weapons, the cash, and the cover in all Israel's efforts to

dispossess the Palestinian people of their land and resources. An

Israeli soldier once told me to go home and deal with the dispossession

of the indigenous people in America before I concerned myself with the

plight of the Palestinians. He was correct in considering the parallels

between genocide in America and ethnic cleansing in Palestine.

While countries smolder and survivors walk among the ruins, a

generation lost to violence and destruction, we congratulate ourselves

on "winning" and move on to the next conflagration. Americans are lost

as well. Lost in our deluded imagination of a country that wishes peace

in the world, we remain blind to the horrors of "shock and awe," drone

attacks, night raids and torture while our government sows carnage in

every direction. US threats to attack Iran are part of a century-old

pattern of violence aimed at ensuring US domination. "Freedom!" we

proclaim, "Democracy! How ungrateful these people are! Can't they see we

have liberated them? Why do they hate us? It can only be because we are

free." We wave our flags, paint stars and stripes on our faces and

chant "USA! USA! USA!

Columbus Day is a good day to reconsider who I am. I have been to Big

Mountain, the Four Corners, and Wounded Knee. I have heard the stories

of relocation, theft, poverty and struggle. I have been to too many

funerals in Marwahin, Jenin, Beit Lahiya and Gaza. I have sat in the

rubble in al-Amiriya, in Qana, in Bint Jbeil, in Rafah, and in Kabul. I

have cried with refugee grandmothers whose families have been scattered

like seeds on the wind. I have cried with mothers whose children were

torn to shreds under laser-guided bombs and whose sons have died as foot

soldiers in our wars of conquest. I have cried with men who have dug

the bodies of their wives and children from the rubble of their homes. I

am intimate with this fella Columbus and I know too well that our

national claim of freedom leaves me disgraced and dishonored.

And the blood flows.

 
That's true. Just for clarification I do think there are a few flaws in the article. I just really want to discuss it and hear some opinions. A lot of the things he's saying are pretty valid and I like the message, but there are definitely some issues
 
There is no possible way that 1 in 4 African American males are imprisoned in the US.

According to the 2010 US Census, there are 38.9 million African Americans. The male half of that population totals 19.45 million. And a quarter of that is 4.8 million people. Yet in 2010 there were only 2.2 million innmates total in the US. There's just no way those numbers add up.
 
Haha oh wow. Yeah I really hate it when people like this, who really have a good point and know how to promote it fuck themselves over on facts and the like.
 
Yeah, I mean sure, but the disease was kinda brought from Europe... But then again them got damn natives did introduce polio to the Old World. Pretty much evens out. Except for the whole rape and pillage thing.
 
history is def a very interesting subject. anyone else ever wonder what other bs the us education system has been subjected to? remember growing up through elementary school and middle school how teachers told us to only get our information from the library?

also op, where this read come from? very very interesting
 
Definitely.

Also, I believe the article came from Truthout.org or something like that. We read it in my social issues class.
 
always, after reading relativity by einstein i questioned my years of physics classes, though relative the results we can get are pretty damn right most all of the time, its still not IT

Anyone ever think about simple stuff like being told America was found by Columbus, then by the same teacher you are told it was actually found by Amerigo Vespucci
 
Really broseph? In Vietnam who were the villagers more afraid of Americans or the vc. Have you seen the picture of the us embassy when we pulled out. They knew they were going to get killed so they begged Americans to take them to america
 
Can you even begin to comprehend how much pain and suffering the usa caused Vietnam?

The Viet Cong were national heroes that liberated their country and people from the imperialist pig dogs aka the united snakes. The few people who begged to leave with the americans were counter-revolutionaries and imperialist collaborators.

 
Americans pigs? Do you know what the vc did to American prisoners let alone their own citizens. Have you ever seen what a vc bugi sticks will do?
 
However much I believe Nam was the biggest waste of money and lives in world history and we had absolutely no place being there, let's try to keep this on task.
 
Agent orange was not know to cause cancer years later much like the pesticides we used on our own crops at the time. My lia do you know how many villages the vc had raped and burned. I'm sure those people begged for the vc to shoot them to end their suffering. I can't Your saying the Americans were savages compared to the vc. Do you also believe that the holocaust didn't happen or stalins five year plans?
 
you're ignoring the millions of people the united states has killed

what do the holocaust and five year plans have to do with anything

 
35jck5d.jpg&size=400x1000
 
Last sentance of the second paragraph. Entire arguement is false.

for those too lazy to look, it is implying that Colombus would have had to go back in time to kill off the remaining indians. Dont think that was possible.

hause
 
Oh wow he really did count to potato there. By no means renders the entire argument false though. I'd assume he mixed up the dates.
 
Bullshit all you want, communism was a failure and the USSR blew cocks. Joseph Stalin was a psychotic animal.

'Nam was stupid, but the VC where peices of shit.

Have fun prancing around with your head up you ass, circle jerking with marxists and Occupying places.

Nagger.
 
thanks for sharing your opinion, right-wing fascist scum

the USSR was great

the usa is bad

Viet Cong were heroes

i'm not an occupy liberal

oh and using a racial slur? Grant should have exterminated your people after the civil war
 
it's not intentional bs, it's just old opinions that have stuck throughout time. every account of anything historical is going to be biased since the author has to choose what to include and why. i just wrote a paper for a class on how events are portrayed differently in textbooks over the last century, and one of the main things i discovered with american history is that it took a while to engrain patriotism and nationalism enough in our culture before we were able to write "less" biased historical accounts. we used to have to be force fed ideas of american exceptionalism in order to bask in our superiority, however now it is a lens through which we subconsciously view everything and it's often more difficult than it should be to revert to the facts and reanalyze an incident
 
Back
Top