Reddit-Style (ish) Up/Down Vothing

Billek

Active member
I would love some up/down voting incorporated into Newschoolers posts. As I get older, I get more and more tired of trawling through 'I'll take a seat here', 'Threads', 'Tahts sooo ghey' posts, especially when there is some worthwhile content in the NS threads.

A simple way to let users take the trash out would make everyone happier. If the users had a way of removing some extremely immature posts, maybe we wouldn't have the designation of 'Best Humor Site'.

Let us clean up our forum NS staff!

The format of this site has everyone addicted, from 10-year olds to some gray-haired bombers. However, as people mature, they grow tired of the childish content that is expected of any site that lets anyone join.

Lets say my idea was put in place;

Some user posts something totally unrelated to the thread, or something that most people would find annoying. If that post accumulated 5, 10, or however many downvotes, it would be hidden from view. Like Reddit, we would have the option of clicking to see what they said, so no one gets left out.

The possibilities are endless! Low-voted posts would be filtered out, good info would remain, and you could even incorporate the karma system into the voting feature.

I'm sure many people do the same thing as me. If I see a really annoying post, I put them at zero karma. What happens if this user posts some bullshit again and they are already at zero karma? I'd love to vote them down so their useless post gets filtered out.

What about the Mods? Sure, they remove offensive content, but what about the huge amount of USELESS content?

If this was some simple forum, I would let it slide, but Newschoolers is at a higher level than that. There are few forums that attract such a large base, and generate such an expansive amount of content.

 
....

.....

I know I'm not the first to think of this, but I wanted to get my word out in a coherent manner.
 
I come here to laugh at the stupidity of others, not for quality entertainment... that being said, seeing the occasional boobs are a plus
 
You can still upvote a comment even if that comment all ready has gotten some down votes. Its only the really terrible comments, that get nothing but downvotes, that get filtered out. Majority rules.
 
Why do you even post if you're going to say stupid shit like this? Contribute to the god damn thread, at least give reasoning as to why it shouldn't be implemented.

Allowing down voting for threads though would be amazing. There is so much shit on NSG that needs to be filtered. For example, https://www.newschoolers.com/ns/forums/readthread/thread_id/680035/. It's just a pointless thread.

Useless shit like that gets posted way too often.
 
Newschoolers: "Resistive to change until it happens, then more stoked than they ever were resistive."

Please, do something like this. A ranking system (even one that doesn't impact karma or whether the post is visible) would fundamentally improve the experience on the site. I fail to understand why things like this are so unpopular with NSers. Anytime a change is made similar to this one, everyone falls in line behind it anyway and comes to like the feature. I've been a member for nearly three years, and I have my theories as to why NSers are so resistive to changes on the site, but I don't think I will ever agree with them.

Change leads to progress. Progress is inevitable; and it's good.
 
Thanks for backing this. I completely agree.

I am baffled by the kids in this thread that say they want to see this stuff. They might just not get what I mean. What if it was all optional? Everyone would be satisfied.

And for the Reddit haters: this system will not turn NS into Reddit, so I don't even want to hear your opinion on the site.
 
Back
Top