I agree with most of you that this case must seems unfair and unreasonable. However, the reasoning delivered in these two paragraphs from the Denver Post article are nearly undeniable:
Connelly said there were 15 accidents on
that jump this season. In the 17 days before Salvini fell 37 feet and
landed on flat, hard snow beyond the jump's landing, 10 people were
injured from similar landings off the same jump, including eight riders
who had to be carried down the mountain by ski patrol, he said. "There was a man a week before who broke his back on the
jump. There was an accident 2 1/2 hours before this accident. The jump
was never changed," Connelly said. "The failure to even look at the
landing area when you have 15 prior injuries I think certainly
qualifies as gross negligence."
The case isn't that some kid got worked on a jump. The case is that 8 riders were badly injured in the two weeks prior to the incident in question, and not one thing was changed to fix what was clearly a PROBLEM.
If one kid goes out and gets worked on a jump, fine, fuck 'em. Chalk it up to lack of skill, lack of concentration, or just plain old bad luck. But when that many people are getting injured and no one's doing anything about it, that is definitely grounds for a gross negligence case.
Its analogous to the McDonald's coffee case, insofar as the critical component of the lawsuit is context. Most people don't know that before McDonald's was sued for its coffee being two hot, 47 distinct complaints had been filed with the corporation about that very problem. In fact, the coffee was so hot, it was only a handful of degrees short of boiling; way beyond a reasonable "hot beverage" temperature. Moreover, the 22 million dollars in damages awarded to the plaintiff was so conceived because thats how much money McDonald's makes on coffee in a single week. The money was awarded to the woman on the grounds of pain and suffering, but the real intent of the ruling was punitive action against McDonald's negligence.
I dunno. I'm not saying the kid is right for doing what he did. But if it really was negligence on the part of the resort, then we should be just as pissed off at Snoqualmie for being irresponsible and disrespectful of our sport as we should be at people like Kenny Salvini who don't respect it on a personal level.