I would take rodgers over vick. Vick is just to much of an injury risk in the first round. I don't believe in taking QBs high though because of how deep the position is. Take a RB. You may be able to get McCoy or Charles then. take one of those guys if you can.
yes you should fucking take vick. rodgers is "safer", but vick finished 16th among running backs last year. 16th. you are getting a flex/second back and an unreal qb threat in 1 pick. clearly do it if you get the chance.
he went 3rd overall in my league, ap went first and chris johnson went second.