to get things started! heres a paper from our good friend leckett!
here is an essay on The Miracle Worker answering how a challenge can provide one with fulfillment and spiritual enrichment:
Many people seek enrichment and spiritual fulfillment by engaging in challenges and activities that they can look back on and take as a personal victory. There are those who would perform daring stunts, such as Evil Knievel, to enhance their personal fulfillment and run through a legacy to be remembered. A daring challenge, not so much like those of Evil Knievel, was undertaken by Annie Sullivan to teach Helen Keller that there is a world with language and commune outside of her. Annie refers to this as “a chicken hatching from its egg” in the sense that Helen has yet to break free of her mental barrier preventing her from understanding the world on her own. But a challenge isn’t a challenge without obstacle. Annie will face many hardships during her enrolment with the Keller’s. She will have to discover a way to teach her while she is blind and deaf; the two most important sense of communication. But not only this, her parents have dealt her astronomic levels of pity for her being, leaving her undisciplined. Annie will have to face discipline, Helen’s condition, and the inevitable pity of her parents in order for her to succeed in her challenge.
Perhaps breaking Helen free of her mental barrier would have been easier if she had been disciplined by her parents into obedience, but this, however, is not the case. Helen is, to simply state, spoiled rotten. If she gets anxious or nervous, her parents won’t hesitate to deal her candy to calm her. When Annie begins her session with Helen, she is immediately opposed to the first thing Annie does negatively to her, which would be Annie trying to take the doll from Helen. The dinner table scene establishes the true disciplinary issues of Helen. She absolutely refuses to obey anything Annie attempts to have her do; such as sit down at the table and eat with cutlery. Instead of engaging to learn, Helen simply puts up a temper tantrum summoned from hell itself over something so small. This leads into the issue of her inexorable nature.
Helen’s lack of discipline has left her scared with a mulish nature, and Annie will have to deal with this in her challenge with Helen. After the dinner scene passes, Helen becomes so detained from Annie that she will run in terrible fear whenever she comes in contact with Annie. Helen now refuses to even let Annie touch her, which has delayed Annie incredibly. Annie decided to lock herself with Helen in a small cabin until Helen had no other choice, but to go by what Annie wants. This, of course, was not an easy challenge. Annie felt a jolt of enlightenment as she finally received the ability to touch Helen once again. This began her teaching all over again; but the two weeks where shortly up. Annie had taught Helen such aspects as folding her napkin, eating with cutlery, and crocheting. Annie desperately needed more time to take Helen further with her teachings, but the pity of her parents denied this.
After the two weeks, at exactly 6 0’clock in the evening, Kate demanded Helen back. This was Annie’s worst fear. Although Annie managed to calm Helen and give her some discipline, the returning of her parents premature of her teaching will have this all collapse into the mess it originated from. At the dinner table this night, Annie’s fear became real. Helen refused to eat with the cutlery given to her and began her whole tantrums over again as she knew she was back with her old family. For all she knew, she was allowed to throw tantrums around her family, as she has not been disciplined against it; only against Annie. James was correct when he said that Helen was “testing” the family to how they will put up with her as her original self once again. This lead to another physical battle between Annie and Helen. Annie brought Helen out to the pump to fill up the pitcher that she had spilled. The pity of Helen’s family once again fought this. Captain Keller insisted Annie leave Helen at the table, but Annie would not have it. And if it wasn’t for the heroic act of James to stand in his father’s way, Annie would not have succeeded in Helen achieving the miracle that was at stake. It finally happened. Helen had finally learned that “things have names” and she was eager to learn everything there was to learn. This enriched and touched Annie in a way she has never experienced. She used be in eternal dept to her brother Jimmie as she felt she had abandoned him in her childhood, but the flashbacks are put to a halt at this point.
Annie has succeeded in teaching a blind/deaf and undisciplined child that things have names, and as Annie’s analogy states: “a chicken hatching from its egg”. This provided her with the fulfillment and spiritual enrichment that she had so desperately sought out throughout the play. She has managed to discipline Helen, and powerfully lecture her family on how their pity for her is Helen’s worst enemy as it will only undo everything Annie has taught her. This is a miracle, and it has been cracked by Annie Sullivan herself, and this victory has propelled her even further to bring Helen to understanding the real world and everything about it.
By: Kyle Leckett