NS METALHEADS

I don't consider "death grunts" or "gutterals" to be vocals at all. I find them to be DISGUSTING!!! Even if they have talent doing them, I think it sounds like some kid burping, or worse.
 
you cant call anything gay when you are using insults like that. honestly-gay to the bone?

and Jack-i think you are in like my top 5 favorite members now due to that fact that you know so much about metal, but have respect for hiphop also.
 
I love hip hop man. Find a post where I criticize true hip hop and I'll admit fault. But you won't so I won't worry.

This conversation isn't about what you ENJOY, it's about respecting a genre of music and not generalizing it all into one giant lump that you call "worthless." It's close minded and ridiculous. But I don't expect anything less from a society of fuck ups.
 
Metal is organised noise and the work of the devil!!! you're going to hell Jack! turn or burn! your kind disgust me! you ahve no rigtht o like metal cos it sucks because of my completely arbitrary hate of it!

Nah but yeah. funny anecdote: i have a bvlack dude in my class who, seriously, out of nowhere went all metal on our asses... he constantly grabs stuff to make a mic and tries to growl. it's the single most hilarious thing ever... i need to film it sometime.
 
sorry jack, but i find a little contreversy in what your saying

"FYI, metal is not Linkin Park, Disturbed, or Godsmack. That "music" is garbage"

"Third: not all metal bands have the growly vocals. Bands like Nevermore and Disturbed have almost ALL clean vocals."

So, is Disturbed metal or not?
 
i hope your fucking joking about post hardcore owning metal! and as far the second part of your post you have no fucking clue. and the post hardcore fucking hardcore scene=fashioncore. just a bunch of fucking scensters
 
oh and disturbed might be metal but they still suck. were not here trying to make you believe all metal is good, because of course there is a fair share of shitty metal bands as there is a huge amount of shitty music in all genres. so what you people need to do is not be so close minded and open your fucking eyes up and be a little more cultured. you dont hear us bashing hip hop or shit like that cuz we also enjoy GOOD hip hop.
 
i never said it was the closet thing to hardcore. and as far as your definition as a metalhead goes i am the farthest thing from that. your whole definition is so far from the truth.
 
i guess i dont know about the 'scene' over in your neck of the woods, but i am fully aware of it all in mine. but as far as i can tell you are pretty much an idiot
 
From your sweeping generalizations about metal, it doesn't seem like you've even know enough about the genre to be making a comparison. Your description of metal music and metal listeners isn't accurate or comprehensive and you're just furthering the misperceptions that most people have of the genre.
 
First post on NS, hello everyone

Hardcore is a direct descendent of Metal, the screaming vocals came from the band Death in the mid 80's and the original hardcore bands that combined the styles of metal, (Sepultura, Crowbar, Prong, CoC) can trace the routes of their style to that band. All of the hardcore now comes from that school of music, even if most of them don't like it. Thats where the name "Death Metal" came from, because they used growly and screamy vocals which are really the same thing but growls use more of the resonance of one's voice.

So yeah, I guess you could say you don't like metal and the hardocre is better, but Hardcore is just a watered down version of metal that is far less technical and far less creative (opinion here) that owes its heritage from Metal and Punk, both groups happily disown Hardcore as a bastard child with down syndrome.

So why is a band like As I Lay Dying considered hardcore, or post hardcore, or post-primal-prepunctual-prepubescent-post-ubiquitous-concurrently-self-justificational diluted-excessivebrakedownial bore-core, or whatever the fuck you want to call a genre that has no reason to be separated from the rest of hardcore, goth, emo and pop music? Whats different about this band than Metal?

Well, The style is very similar to metal, double bassing, pinched harmonics, metal style screaming, and fast melodic riffs. Its more metal than not, however, the themes of their music is really the thing that separates them, which boils down to lyrics and overall message.

Lets compare lyrics, shall we...

When This World Fades - As I Lay Dying

You meant the world to me

All I have now is memories

Your love brought joy to my heart

You meant the world to me

Tears of sorrow stream from my broken soul

But I will see you again

When this world fades away

I will see you again

Here is a line from a contemporary of As I Lay Dying, considered Metal, with similar instrumental style.

The Black Dahlia Murder - Elder Misanthropy

blood of the ancient one is burning through my veins

the blood of gods man's never known

i am the one who cannot die

i am the the killer for all time

seeds of infinite hate i've sown

walk the earth enshrouded in its darkness

eclipsing, i claim the flesh of man

ageless i remain with vengeance on my breath

revolted by the meek

So as you can see, the As I Lay Dying lyrics are whining about a girl who left him. Wow, original every so exciting. The Black Dahlia Murder song is a song ABOUT ZOMBIES COMING BACK TO LIFE. One band is funny, the other isn't. One band has fun and plays extremely technical riffs and has a good time singing funny songs about ZOMBIES. As I Lay Dying writes incredibly morose, trite lines about losing a girl. There's the difference folks, one is tongue in cheek, the other tear in eye, thumb in mouth, sucking on it. Any band who takes themselves as seriously as most Hardcore bands is boring and unoriginal because they spend all their time trying to convey some stupid sad message to appeal to 14 year olds instead of developing musically. Don't get me wrong, theres a lot of terrible metal bands out there that take themselves too seriously, and they're getting popular and getting spots right next to all the terrible hardcore bands on headbangers ball. Doesn't mean any of that is good though.

"i see fare to much color in this room lets taint this room black the color of darkness" - I suppose this could have been funny, but words are misspelled and it doesn't make any sense. Metal is easy to make fun of, but you have to try harder than this, ShadowPuppet7
 
so um, im pretty sure hradcore is just annoying. they name there songs stupid shit, have seizures on stage, and its not hard to play. and i got the "not hard to play" part partly from my friend who was in a hardcore band, and partly from listening myself. listen to what you want, but im pretty sure bands like Usurper and Black Dahlia Murder, who as stated above, sing about zombies, time travel, werewolves and other such topics.

o yeah-if you wanna hear a crazy scream, listen to "Slaughterstorm" by Usurper. at the end its 33 seconds of a scream that sounds as if no one but the devil himself could produce such a noise
 
Straight hardcore's gay coz it sounds the fuckin same as it did in the eighties, and to make musical progress a few bands had to label themselves 'post-hardcore' (I respect post-hardcore and love it) coz they couldn't be innovative and creative within the musical boundaries of hardcore, however...

Has anyone ever heard of 'post-metal'? I think not, metal has various subgenres like death metal, black metal, grindcore etc. coz it has the capability to evolve and change since the only defining characteristic of 'metal' is a sense of musicality and technical superiority over any other form of rock (arguably)
 
he was talking about loss and suffering BECAUSE OF A GIRL. Megadeath is singing about death, god, and satan-not vaginas.
 
i wasnt saying all metal was about satan, because its not, but there is no denying that some of it is.

but those megadeath lyrics-to me anyway-seem to be about the end of the world and him standing before God(or the gods) on that day, while they are deciding whether he should go to heaven or hell.

hell=assumed home of satan, so those lyrics indirectly refer to satan.
 
nice choice: but i tend to prefer the following:

He had alot to say. He had alot of nothing to say. We'll miss him. So long. We wish you well. You told us how you weren't afraid to die. Well then, so long. Don't cry. Or feel too down. Not all martyrs see divinity. But at least you tried. Standing above the crowd he had a voice that was strong and loud. We'll miss him. Ranting and pointing his finger at everything but his heart. We'll miss him. No way to recall what it was that you had said to me, Like I care at all. So loud. You sure could yell. You took a stand on every little thing and so loud. Standing above the crowd, he had a voice so strong and loud and I swallowed his façade cuz I'm so eager to identify with someone above the ground, someone who seemed to feel the same, someone prepared to lead the way, with someone who would die for me. Will you? Will you now? Would you die for me? Don't you fuckin' lie. Don't you step out of line. Don't you fuckin lie. You've claimed all this time that you would die for me. Why then are you so surprised to hear your own eulogy? You had alot to say. You had alot of nothing to say. Come down. Get off your fuckin cross. We need the fuckin space to nail the next fool martyr. To ascend you must die. You must be crucified for your sins and your lies. Goodbye...
 
chill your actually slightly wrong. Bands like hate eternal are satanic. But your right in saying that 99.9% of metal is not satanic.

but there are bands that are satanic. but thats like .1% of all the metal in the world.
 
OOOOOHHHHHHHH!!! YOU'RE GOING TO NEED SOME LOTION FOR THAT BURN!

But anyways, "to each his own" would be appropriate here. But also keep in mind that you can't really tell people your opinion is right and then spit out that saying, it's a bit hypocritical of you.
 
i honestly dont see what you are trying to get at by posting a blog written by someone who has yet to participate in this thread.

if you didnt want to hear what we had to say about your opinion, you should have never said "the arguing can start now".

and another thing-earlier in the thread you said "metal is for fat people who cant rock out on stage". so what exactly is your definition of rocking out? Having a seizure? cuz thats what all the hardcore bands do with there sweet "slam-dancing". and why the fuck does it matter. this is fucking rock. not madonna. who cares what kinda moves they have. they could rip you a new asshole with a guitar pick.
 
Michael Amott wants to blow out your eardrums to spare you from listening to that trash.

Arch%20Enemy-Michael%20Amott%20&%20Krank.jpg
 
"alright mister"i create a new account and try and appaear all new but yet so smart""

Alright... probably shouldn't even dignify this with a response

"i was just stereotyping them, just how many stereotype people who listen to "post hardcore" to be scene kids who cry and being all depressed"

Yeah but the stereotype was neither apt or funny, and its pretty easy to get it right.

"wait sorry i did not know a whole gendre of music enveloping thousands upon thousands of bands was constructed around only 1 band."

I was merely speaking of the vocal style. This isn't really uncommon, how many bands before Judas Priest and Rainbow had vocals like them? Not really any that I can think of, the first bands to growl and scream all out like Hardcore and Metal do now were grindcore and death metal bands from the mid and early 80s, Venom, Death, Napalm Death, Deicide, if you know any bands that did that style before these guys, I'll be all ears. Who played guitar like Chuck Berry before him, who played the guitar like Jimi Hendrix, and then Randy Rhoads? There is a reason that those guys are legends. Soloing guitar came from Charlie Parker in the 1940's, unheard of at the time. So yes, you can tie certain style back to a single person, because there is a first time for everything.

As for being not as good if less creative, yeah you're right, if the music is good then it doesn't matter that much. The lack of technicality and creativity is definitely a deterrent for those who don't already like the genre. Most metal out there, not the shit you might hear on the radio, is quite technical and creatively so, and tends to earn more respect amongst listeners who don't already like Metal.

Yeah, Megadeth lyrics can sometimes be mournful like a lot of metal, but they rarely use tired old cliches like As I Lay Dying about sorrow and losing a chick.

Also, the song Elysian Fields is a story taken from Homer about a field of perfect happiness for those who Zeus preferred. He may have applied it a little to is own life, but it is really a story about reaching this place. And for god sakes, its not about losing a woman, whenever I hear a heavy song about losing a girl, first of all, its never good because its trying to be sad and pitiful and its fucking played out. Doesn't mean losing a girl is no small matter, but it has no place in heavy music IMO.

I guess the thing about hardcore is that it is pretentiously sorrowful, making the assumption that his feelings are somehow worth knowing about and people should respect it. A story about someone doing that that is a a well written, complete story and not just whining is another thing, if you know any hardcore bands that do this please let me know. Its a matter of tastefulness.

Yeah maybe TBDM doesn't take their lyrics that seriously, but taking yourself that seriously like AILD is stupid IMO and its cliche.

An artist can take his music seriously, but Adolescent angst is again, trite and so overdone that they aren't saying anything new and it brings the music down to a simple emotional level. Some metal bands take their lyrics very seriously, but they tend to tell stories and vary the subject matter between songs, hardcore doesn't seem to do that. This isn't true of all metal, but its the whole package, and metalheads do love the heaviness, but without a pursuit of technicality and creativity, its boring to myself and the other metal heads in this forum.

THE BASIC TRUTH OF MUSIC:

All genre's have their chessiness, the fans of which have learned to find humor in or embrace it.

Music cannot be judged on technicality and creativity alone. You have to define your taste for yourself. Technicality and Creativity (although harder) can be somewhat measured, but if you don't like it thats the way it is.

Hardcore definitely appears to me to be less technical and more derivative than good metal, perhaps I haven't heard the right bands, but I've heard a lot of them and so far none of them have impressed me in any way. Its hard to have respect for a Genre when the bands themselves go out of their way to dress a certain way and wear hairspray and makeup and the crowds that the pull are kids that do the same thing and don't know anything about the scene. I personally do not like metalheads and the crowds that go to metal shows, but at least they don't go out of their way to look like idiots who all dress the same and wear make up. In fact, they don't really go out of their way to do anything, thats why they smell bad and don't cut their hair. :)
 
This kid obviously has never been to a metal show. He stereotypes it just like anyone without an open mind.

Here's the truth, you like show in your music as opposed to talent. Did you ever wonder that maybe people who play metal dont have the time in the song to just swing the guitar around their neck and fuck off.

Maybe its because metal doesnt havent a break down in the song every 30 seconds. I dont care if you like hardcore or emo, but what I do care about is the fact that you stereotype the genre as satanists. Truth is, you're uneducated and pissed off because you're finally going thru pubarty.
 
im pretty sure im not the one that needs to take it less seriously. i mean whos the one whos been in hear defending hardcore and post-hardcore, and all the other fancy ways of saying "playing rubber bands around a shoebox while dropping your moms pots and pans after you stole your sisters pants".
 
Jokes on Shadow7, I'm not a skier!!! I'm just a vigilant metalhead summoned by Oden to defend the name of good metal. But seriously if hes going to come into a Metal Forum and dis on metal he should expect such a thing. I don't go to Hardcore or Punk forums/shows just to tell them that they suck.
 
Just like that Tellytubbie avatar? Or how about the use of the word "Steeze" in a normal sentence? Or how about a "Steeze" that is associated with Pencils?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top