I quite like it, but it's of a different style than Hot Fuss. I find that the composition of the songs is more agressive, while still maintaining the feel of the killers.
The album takes itself alot more seriously than the first, Rollingstone disliked it, taking issue with it's bruce-springstein-esque road anthems and the fact that the killers, like most indie bands (in their opinion), should not take themselves seriously.