Yes i am saying most people are that far off with a guide. Unless you buy one of the better guides the manufacturing techniches allow for about 1degree of erorr. Add in irregulatiries in manufacturing of the base (as you said most skis to not come flat), and you have another degree of error. Then add in general human error just from not being smooth when your tunning and your up in the 3-4 degree range. Which is still relatively small, and most people don't even notice.
As for what i said about heat treating, i sincerely believe it isn't necessary to tune a park ski unless youre also using it in the pipe. The most beneficial way to tune for park is to just deburr and wax when you need it, keeps the edges stronger, and leaves more material there. For pipe however it is necessary to tune, and if your doing mostly jumps and barely any rails its not a bad idea to tune. I was just saying the way to make your skis the best for jibbing is to not tune, or detune them, just to debur them when you get the larger chunks of edge damaged.
Catching edges has never been an issue for me, and the way i have done with all my park skis is to ski them on snow for a week or so hard to detune the edges with the snow/ice. And then use them in the park on whatever i want, deburring them and waxing them as i see damage or feel slow respectively.