Not compared to 3,2, and 1. All were way better games. Reach was an attempt to mash parts of COD into Halo and it just doesn't work. Grenades are OP, DMR isn't as fun as BR was, when you go 1v1 against someone else it becomes a lot more of a crapshot, and I just don't think its fun. I mean, teamwork is still important, but its a whole different style that is not really halo. IMO reach was a disappointment.