English Majors?

Freeskier22

Member
Im writing a college essay for Pomona College, the prompt is :

Although it may appear to the contrary, we do know that people have a

life beyond what they do to get into college. Tell us about an

experience you’ve had outside of your formal classroom and

extracurricular activities that was just plain fun.

I would greatly appreciate any criticism but here is my essay thus far (work in progress)

Snow, although normally a soft and fluffy material becomes a

penetrating projectile when blowing at high speeds. When it comes into contact with one’s face,

the effect is not only pain, but cold.

The knife edge ridge was nothing

short of daunting; a 50 foot drop to the right and a sheet of steep ice on the

left. I was only three minutes into the

hike up the glacier before I realized that it wouldn’t be as easy as it had

initially looked. My older brother was

trailing behind me by about 50 yards and I turned back to see him struggling

just as I was. I had been informed of the differential between the thickness of

sea level air and mountain air, but did not anticipate such a drastic difference.

I swung my skis back and forth, planting them in the snow in an agonizing rhythmic

motion known as bootpacking. As I neared

the hole in the rocks at the top, I noticed that my brother had caught up to me

and was right behind me. We paused a

minute and took a rest and began talking – why were we up here anyways? We finally reached the top, and in a dizzy

blur of cold wind and gasping breath I let out a shout of triumph. As we

strapped on our skis and looked over the precipice down the maze of rock

outcroppings guarding a few narrow couloirs, the question resounded, “why were

we here?” I turned to my brother and gave him the silent nod and grin – an adrenaline

junkie’s first tell. We both jumped out

from the cornice, and began our descent into each of two different couloirs. Two

turns in the knee deep powder and I fell right off of the face of the earth, I was

in the zone, a nirvana of white haze and smooth motion.

 
i would've kept reading it. hopefully someone at the college who reads it skis too, then you are in.
 
Im not an english major, but I have written alot of shit in college and enjoy it.

In my opinion, the words you chose make it sound like you are trying to hard, like you used a thesaurus. Thesauruses are good and all, but sometimes they make shit to long to read, when you read a technical word for every verb/noun/etc. It sounds like they just want you to explain your hobby and why you do it, how you started (Make it somewhat short and sweet, but still written well) and then explain why it was so fun and different than alot of normal experiences.

Explain how the trip all started (i.e. why were you there,where is it, who was all with you) And fuck, write like 2 pages (double spaced), yours seemed way to short.
 
Still working, but heres where i am

Prompt: Although it may appear to the

contrary, we do know that people have a life beyond what they do to get into

college. Tell us about an experience you’ve had outside of your formal

classroom and extracurricular activities that was just plain fun.[/b]

Snow, the normally feathery, fluffy

material becomes a penetrating projectile when blowing at high speeds. When it comes into contact with one’s face,

the effect is not only painful, but a biting cold. I peered up towards the peak

and, began my hike.

The knife edge ridge was nothing

short of daunting; a 50 foot drop to the right and a sheet of steep ice on the

left. I was only three minutes into the

hike up the glacier before I realized that it wouldn’t be as easy as it had

initially looked. My older brother David

was trailing behind me by about 50 yards and I turned back to see him

struggling just as I was. I had been informed of the differential between the

thickness of sea level air and mountain air, but did not anticipate such a

drastic difference. I swung my skis back and forth, planting them in the snow

in an agonizing rhythmic motion known as bootpacking. As I neared the hole in the rocks at the top,

I noticed that David had caught up to me and was right behind me. We paused a minute and took a rest and began

talking – why were we up here anyways?

We finally reached the top, and in a dizzy blur of cold wind and gasping

breath I let out a shout of triumph. As we strapped on our skis and looked over

the precipice down the maze of rock outcroppings guarding a few narrow couloirs,

the question resounded, “why were we here?” I turned to my brother and gave him

the silent nod and grin – an adrenaline junkie’s first tell.

We both jumped out from the

cornice, and began our descent into each of two different couloirs. Two turns

in the knee deep powder and I fell right off of the face of the earth; I was in

the zone, a nirvana of white haze and smooth motion. Out of the corner of my

eye, I saw my brother’s cloud of snow as he exited to my left side into a

gladed area. My heart skipped a beat as

I remembered the “Permanently Closed: Cliff Area” sign. I raced through the remaining portion of the run

towards what I anticipated to be a disaster. Around a large spruce and I saw a

single ski. Bad sign. Then I was in the snow. Until I wiped the snow off of my goggles I

had no idea what had happened, but after surveying the area, I noticed the

sapling that had caught my right ski.

Still dazed, I heard a chuckling sound from under a thin layer of snow

off to the opposite side as the cliff – my brother! We both laughed at the

ridiculous position of one another, and the frantic manner in which we had come

to them. The moral of the story… there

is none, but that does not mean the experience was meaningless.
 
English Major/Teacher Here - I will be honest

1. Calm down on the hyperbole - We get it already, and so would your college admin. So ease up on the drama, and purple language, it read like an overcooked ham - Words like "resounded" are used inappropraitely -

2. Weak ass excuses for endings - "well the moral of the stroy is...oh there is none" - sound, well, they sound kind of preachy - It sounds clever in your head, but to a reader (a trianed reader) it sounds "preachy" and off topic -

You are wrtiting about a fun, dynamic event -

Try to develop your relationship with your brother - write about him for a paragraph or two - character development is key -

Avoid specific terms to skiing - We know what they mean, your reader does not - so keep the vernacler very pedestrian -

Why did you hike that run - is there a story behind it - goals? etc...

give them something more than a momment of time

 
Do you really want the people at the college know you don't respect posted signs?

maybe it would be best to leave that tidbit out.
 
Excellent criticism - especially about the vernacular.

English minor myself, 760 SAT verbal, blah blah blah.

Express your feelings, sibling relationship, environment descriptions, etc in the SIMPLEST, MOST CONCISE way possible - while not losing or limited what you are trying to say - i used to be a chronic "over-writer", thesaurus user, etc - it can really hurt your writing, even if it sounds good and utilizes impressive vocabulary. Not to sound cliche, but really take your time thinking about the most vivid bits of the memory of your hike/ride down - and ***instead of detailing every little bit, use those bits to stimulate the reader to see and feel what you did at the time, so that he/she can truly see it as you did - your goal? have the reader think of exactly what you do when you recollect the experience - and nothing else. I know it sounds simplistic, and its not an easy thing to do, but don't TELL the reader about the experience - build the experience itself with your words.
 
thats basicially what i was going to say (yeah I'm one to) avoid excess language and snazzy words they make it sound like your trying to hard. Like the guy above me said, don't describe every detail of what happened, let the readers imagination build the experience for them. A sign of a skilled writer is saying loads, with the fewest words possible, look at minimalists like Hemingway.
 
Back
Top