My song by song review
Broken Things - Top 3 songs on the album. Great start, great to have lillywhite back. Lyrically not quite big 3 level, but a vast improvement over BW/SU
Belly Belly Nice - Cool and funky musically, lyrically unimpressive. Reminds me quite a bit of SMLAM, with a little Seven thrown in. Not terrible, but not anywhere near my favorite on the album.
Mercy - Love what Lillywhite did with this, the layering is phenomenal, leaps and bounds ahead of the live version (not to mention nice knowing you arent going to get hit with the turd of a song Out of My Hands is which popped up so much this summer).
Gaucho - Almost a Stone like riff, very cool. Love the music, love Timmy and Jeff going crazy during the second chorus. Lyrically the chorus is meh, and the please wake up line is cheesy, but this song is still good, I can take his Stand Up like, beat-you-over-the-head obvious politics in his lyrics when the music is so good.
Sweet - A cute song that gets a bad rep. I was there for the debut at Caravan last summer, its a fun little song, I just wish the band came in earlier.
The Riff - Hands down my favorite track on the album. Awesome musically, good lyrics, all around a fantastic tune. Funny how the album is more layered/subtle, and the live version more in your face, kind of like Dont Drink the Water was on BTCS.
Belly Full - Awesome to have the token Dave solo track earlier on the album. Almost feels like an improv by him not unlike in a live setting.
If Only - Funky tune, loved it live, quite like it on the album. Lots of fun.
Rooftop - The first verse/guitar almost reminds me of U2. Kind of a different sound to the band, but a good song.
Snow Outside - Second favorite track on the album. Cant wait to hear that outro jam become insane live.
Drunken Soldier - Musically fantastic, lyrically alright, though again, its sad Dave has lost his subtlety that he had in earlier albums. Everything is very straightforward now. Between the intro and outro jams, I can see this becoming Seek Up epic status.
Overall a great album, and a huge step in the right direction for the band. Is it big 3 status? No, but Im not sure anyone in the band is in a place in their lives where they can really write music like that any more. Still worlds better than Stand Up and Big Whiskey, and a good bit better than Everyday as well. Wonderful hearing Boyd utilized more, and Jeff has really come into his own as a part of the band, taking some influence from Roi but still doing his own thing.