ok, i wont calculate it all over, but he will end up with about 2-3 ints more per season as brady (also 2-3 tds more) as brady does with about 200 yds more.
i am just saying this, because most people think of manning "lighting it up" in the reg. season (compared to brady) considering both their career stats, but they dont take into account that brady basically played 4 seasons less.
if manning and brady would end up playing the same amount of effective seasons (they wont though), their career stats will be similar with manning having a edge in tds and yds but brady having the edge in ints.
so the main point for people taking manning over brady isnt that much of an argument. both are playing very well in the regular season.
BUT brady constantly did everything to win in the postseason, whereas manning is not that prolific in big games.
so the only thing manning does better (and is great at, tbh) is dissecting Ds before the snap. he is almost a coach and really good at all these audibles.
but then again, he does the same thing over and over. 1) hard count 2) look who is moving up the line 3) change play/protection 4) snap. the chargers destroyed him because they were the first (from all colts game i watched) to move around almost randomly when he is doing his hard count thingy, thus leaving him unsure about the defensive play called. idk why noone else is doing this more.