Everyone I know who has moved to Logan either moved to SLC soon after or tried to get out of Logan often. It's definitely not the worst town in Utah, but it has serious morman vibes if you aren't into that. Some have called it more morman than BYU, which I frankly don't believe but something to consider.
Than being said, they have a lot of programs that the U doesn't have, especially natural resources and wildlife biology stuff. It probably wouldn't be the worst year ever, but you would want to get out to the U pretty quick if you don't mesh with their culture/programs. A kid I know got kicked out of school just for getting caught with beer in the dorms.
The U is awesome. SLC is one of the best cities in the West. Can't go wrong there unless you don't do well at a large campus.