If your 6'1" 185 I think the t-hall is not the best choice if you hit bigger jumps and charge lines. Who ever said that the extra $200 is not worth paying for just name is smoking more than harold and kumar, because its $50. And if you love to butter and press its worth the money. Also who ever said that the alpha 1 is has an edge of 120, and gets shaky at high speeds is also smoking to much. The alpha 1's have a very minimal amount of rocker and considering k2 put rocker on its carving skis, and volkl is next year i would say they carve fine.... admittedly they do get a little shaky when trying to straight line ice down a couloir but then again ever ski is, except maybe the mothership. Their is a difference between edge touching when you are standing still and when you are arcing a turn. The alpha 1's rocker makes it better in all mountain situations as long as its not big mountain. The ar7 is one of the best traditional park skis out their, and one of the best park skis when it comes to all mountain. the only thing i would change about the alpha 1 is make it a little bit wider. If you want to land bigger spins, get better on and out of rails, and become much better spining switch then the alpha 1 is for you, especially when you consider your weight and height.... the only thing I would be worried about is that the 182 might be to small for you, if it was a little bit longer or a little wider it would be perfect, but i still think its your best choice.... What size ski do you currently ski?