better overall?
dude you cant say that about boots, boots arent like skis. they are only as good as the fit, and to know the fit you need to try on the boots.
either boot could be horribly uncomfortable for you if they dont fit you right.
never buy a boot based on someone elses opinion, or on hype.
you cant compare the boots side by side because its all personal whether or not the boot is good. Two people can test both these boots and have completely opposing opnions, it all comes down to how well it fits you.
i recomend you go to a shop, try on as many pairs as you can, and when youve decided, spend at least 20 minutes walking around in them. so many people rush through buying boots and they pay for it dearly when theyve got mad shinbang or someother problem.