woah, woah, woah...it's not like trading Desean guarantees a return to the days of Fred Ex, Ole' Alligator Arms Pinkston, Greg Lewis, or I've never gotten separation from a DB ever James Thrash. Maclin and Avant are both better than either of the guys you mentioned, so I don't know that your comparison is fair. We also know that there are an abundance of FA WR's available this year. You honestly think the Birds and Jackson will come together and figure out a long term deal? I can't see it.
I hear what you're saying though, in that to essentially rent him this year in order to make a run is an option, but then what? Let him walk and get nothing at all in return? I'd rather try and replace his touches with a couple of guys—like using Shady in the passing game more, I disagree with you there and about the injury angle (much more likely to get banged up between the tackles than catching gimmes in the flats) and trade him for some value or possibly depth elsewhere, then to let him walk next year.
Hey, if they get a deal done and he's satisfied and gets his fucking head out of his ass, that's great, love to see it. There's no doubt that DJack is a top tier talent and about as dangerous in space as anyone in the league. But again, I have my doubts, and I'm also concerned to see what a big money long term contract does to his work ethic and general entitled attitude.
As far as LB, I'd actually rather the Birds draft either Kuechly or the kid out of Cal. Burfict is a headcase, a questionable motor guy who takes plays off that he doesn't think he's "in", he's slow, he's a poor run/pass recognizer. Burfict brings the wood, blows up plays, and is a human highlight reel, but I think he's a terrible fit in Philly. Since BDawk left, the Birds haven't had a defensive leader, and they could really use a character locker room guy, and a guy that can essentially qb the d. I see now that you said to draft in him in the 3rd or 4th so I guess if he's on the board still it'd be a value pick so I see what you're saying, but if they bring him in, I think you need to still target one of the other FAs you mentioned or possibly Fletcher. On the other hand, I think Kuechly could come in and be a leader from jump and has infinitely better instincts then Burfict, never mind the measurables both physically and mentally. The general consensus after the Combine was that Burfict was the WORST interview out 315 kids.
But, as you and I both know, we'll draft 76,000 d-linemen with glass bones and string cheese ligaments anyway, soooo......I wouldn't be shocked if they bring Mamula to camp...