NFL QB Power Ranking Thread

white+wolf

white+wolf

Member
1. Tod Brady aka GOAT

2. Aaron Rodgers

3. Peyton Manning

4. Drew Brees aka domebitch

5. Eli Manning

6. Rapistberger

7. Matt Ryan

8. RG3

9. Schaub

10. Joe Flacco

11. Andrew Luck

12. Dalton

9001. Fitzpatrick

9002. Steve McNair

90013. Matt Sanchez

 
id change 9-12 to 9 luck

10 dalton

11 freeman

12 flacco

houston is a power running team now and josh freeman is legit
 
1354064880324.png
 
Also, it's sad that Alex Smith loses his starting job after going to the NFC Championship game but Mark Sanchez still starts. Colin Kaepernick is good tho
 
haha yea but who knows how thats going to work out. I think Jim Harbaugh is a little over rated. Also, the more tape teams have on Kaepernick the harder its going to be for him (Cam).
 
I think it's hard to say Harbaugh is over rated considering how the 49ers were before he took over. Also, he was a nfl qb so I think he has a good understanding of the game.
 
Lets go by average fantasy points in 2012...

RG3

Brady

Brees

Rodgers

P. Manning

Newton

Ryan

Stafford

Dalton

Freeman

...

...

...

...

Sanchez

 
Because he is a 1st year player. He and Luck will be the two big stars in the next 5 years. Plus his stats are great and he came to a terrible team and has a decent record, he is easily

The best QB in the Nfl
 
Alright then, who's better? Look at what RG3 has to work with and compare it to someone like Tom Brady. Any QB first second or third string could do well with all Brady's options.
 
Brady has been doing it for over a decade. RG3 has done it for half a season. after RG3 leads his team to 5 superbowls he can be mentioned with Brady.

And sure, any second string QB could do what brady does. He very well might be the greatest QB of all time. Top 5 easy. But your right, hes just had recievers for the past decade who make him look good.
 
Ya, Eli is the 5th best, because his numbers have been soooo great as if late. Do you even watch/ever played football and or quarterback, or are you just guessing?
 
Seriously if RG3 was the starting QB for the patriots he would be averaging much more point for them because of their athletic ability. RG3 is much stronger, faster and has a great arm while Brady just has a good arm
 
thats what im saying, he is the most mediocre qb in the league. I laugh when people put flacco and elite in the same sentence, thats a fucking joke
 
im not saying RG3 is bad. hes a rookie. wait till there is a whole season of film on him. To say hes better than Brady is just dumb. Besides, you are referencing things that arent measurable. athletic ability? tell me how thats working out for Romo, Vick, Newton. Arm strength? I might give some merit to completion %, TD/INT but arm strength isnt a stat.

I will measure a QB based on what they have accomplished in their careers.

Brady has a .776 winning percentage and 3 super bowl rings.

RG3 has played 11 games

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top