i didn't really want to get into this argument, but felt the need after your comment. The fact of the matter is that guitar hero is a different game then a game like NCAA football. Guitar hero is a simulation of a real instrument. Now im not saying that if you are good at Guitar Hero you will be good at guitar, but that fact is that it is a simulation, whereas your football game is essentially just mashing some buttons on a controller. If a game came out where you actually went through the motions of throwing the ball, running, kicking etc, then yes i would raise the question of why you are wasting so much time with a simulation and not actually playing football. There is a difference between the games you describe and therefore your argument is not valid in my opinion. You are comparing simulation to game, its the difference between having the money to buy a plane and playing Medal of Honor Air force and useing a flight simulator with yolk, control panel and pedals. If you use the first its a game, but when you use the second you are simulating the real thing when you could actually be able to perform the real activity. Now granted this is not the best analogy because flying a plane involves danger and depends on other factors, but i think it is easy to understand the just of what i am saying.