Probably the recoils, because of what you're going to be skiing on them. The punnishers are (from what I've heard) a very stiff fully cambered comp type park ski like the suspects. Meant for going big and fast off of monster jumps. Recoils are medium flex with mustache rocker and are 90 underfoot, so they'll be a lot more playful, but you'll still be able to make them go big if you want to (just watch clayton villa). Also, if you're in the trees in light powder, the all terrain rocker will be a lot more surfy and fun, while still retaining park ability. For strictly high performance park use, go punnisher. For more playful park use and all mountain, go recoils.