Comfort is solely up to each individual so I'm not sure others results in one liner vs another would be similar to yours. Looks like the tongue style liners are on most of the lower end boots, probably because theres less of the intuition material, so manufacturing costs stay down. If you're looking for suggestions on which style of liner would be best for you you'd be best to consult a boot fitter. Different styles of liners work for others for different reasons, and it's next to impossible for people on the internet to make suggestions for your needs.