You're stupid.
When you get 212 critics with 196 of them positive, I'm pretty sure that tells something don't you think?
Those guys watch and rate movies as a JOB, they are paid because their abilities to recognize good directing, acting, cinematography and such are on point.
As for Gosling, plz watch his filmography and get back to me:
- Ides of March
- Blue Valentine
- Fracture
- Half Nelson
- Lars and the Rear Girl
And Terrence Malick wants him for his next film, which tells a lot.