You're also comparing $1000+ cameras to the GL1 that you can pick up for under $500 now. For a first camera, I don't think it would be terrible. You can learn the manual controls of filming. I guess I compare it to buying a brand new pair of skis to with the latest technology to learn park, or a used pair off your buddies to see if you like it. At least with the GL1, if he decides that filming isn't for him, he isn't out $2k.