Can...

the following statement is true:

the previous statement is false.

same concept of contradictory truths. its cant be solved.
 
thhis is a total theoretical question that i am assuming you asked so you could spark a controversy over ns and then indulge in its fruit, i am going to assume that this thread may go on for pages, sides will be taken, karma will be raised, words will be thrown, but this question contradicts itself.
 
if i wanted to not be able to lift something, i'd make a rock i cannot lift, why else would i do such thing?and remember, god doesn't change his mind...
 
"A stone so heavy that God cannot lift it" is not a possible object, like a round triangle, or a square circle. because God cannot lift it, and God can lift anything. If he is going to break the laws of the Universe to create the stone, then he can break them again when he goes to lift it.
 
If god can do anything then he could suspend the rules of logic in order to do it. Of course admitting this relegates any question of god to the realm past logic where there aren't any answers.
 
ah hahahaha i was reading all your posts this whole time thinking "who the fuck is this guy, saying these things as if he were god" and then i looked at your username
 
Seeing as there is no such thing as god, the answer is no.

Prove to me that god is real, and can make anything, let alone a rock, then I will begin to contemplate your question.
 
yes, he can

god wants to make a stone that he cannot lift, there for when he tries to lift the stone (with the knowing he made it unliftable in mind) it does not lift, or else the stone would not be what god made. dog doesnt want to lift the stone

if god wants to make that stone liftable, then he will be able to lift it
 
here is my contribution to this interesting and dumbass thread.
wh3w45h.jpg

 
HEY GOD, sit the fuck down and listen to this, "Science says that any mass can be moved with enough force, no stone is unliftable"

done.
 
when i went to a catholic high school, that question was on one of my religion tests.

i skipped it.
 
agreed. Btw have you seen the new Jim Jeffries HBO special? He talks about god being an asshole in it and it's so hilarious. Youtube it if you're bored, i think you'll get a kick out of it. Anybody anti-religion will enjoy it.
 
i'm taking philosophy of religion. This is one of the many arguments against the existence of G.O.D.

perhaps a little too thick for NSG to have a decent conversation about (spare a few intelligent posts)
 
people shouldnt question wether or not god can do things, they should rather question wether or not god is supposed to be able to do these things, thereby i mean, if there is some sort of god, do we really expect him to be all mighty ? Couldnt god just be a homie in heaven controlling our karma ?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top