I hear what you're sayin'. It definitely depends on the cut of the collar and on the tie itself. I'd agree that with a very narrow collar & a skinny tie, such as the one you presented, a full windsor would look incredibly tacky. However, with a wider cut collar & wider tie, such as those on an Express 1MX shirt as an example, I think a half, 4, or pratt looks too small. I guess it's all in the pairing.