Atomic punx base crack?

Hello NS!I bought a pair of Atomic punx 09/10 and loved them like i loved my last pair of punx's 08/09. But after two weeks of shredding this happened. The crack is 15-20cm long and its pretty wide. Its almost as deeo as the ski is thick. This really sucks. My local shop told me that they can't give me new ones because you can clearly see that i've been railing with my skis. No shit I've been railing? I bought these because i want to ride park, isnt railing then obvious? What should I do with this, do u think Atomic would send me new ones?
Peace
1270798714atomic-punx-09-10-base-crac.jpg

 
WTF?

Is the edge pulling out, or did the base just crack along the edge's teeth? Doesn't look like a core shot that was placed with wonderful precision... hmmm
 
Looks like the whole sidewall and edge is blowing out and has snapped the base off as well instead of just popping out.
I guess you could epoxy the hell out of it but it'll probably smash off pretty fast.
And you're probably boned, warranty-wise. That would be impact damage for sure.
 
I've been telling people that these skis have shitty durability and that Atomic's warranty department doesn't care for 3 years now.
 
I don't understand why people make these threads. How about you just call the company and then you'll know.... They'll either say that you're out of luck or they'll help you out.

NS is not the warranty department for every single ski company
 
This happened to my friend's (bpAIR) 08/09 Punx. Then that edge piece broke and would catch in the ground.

Spark Note: Don't get Atomics.
 
wow! Same happend to my punx (09-10) after 6-7 days of skiing! There's a picture on my profile. Luckily my shop gave me new ones!
 
Wow, haven't seen that before.
Judging by how deep the crack goes I'd guess that there is a delam between within the core which led to the split occuring. Judging by the location of the crack I'd say its most likely between the edge of the wood core and the plastic sidewall. If this is the case then I'd say its a manufacturing defect or a flaw in the engineering of the ski. There are a couple of possible causes if his is the case:
One, there was a 'dry spot' between the sidewall and wood which would grow under load and lead to failure between the sidewall and wood core (which in turn lead to the crack in the base). This would be a manufacturing defect as there shouldn't be dry spots (dry spot is simply where there isn't any adhesive/glue).
Two, I'd guess the sidewalls are made from a UHMWPE (like P-Tex). UHMWPEs have low surface energies (i.e. not sticky) which makes it hard to get a good bond to the material. This is countered by choosing an adhesive designed for the sticking low surface energy plastics. If they didn't use such an adhesive then the joint would be weak and readily fail. This would be a materials selection mistake. Another way of getting around the low energy of the material is to treat it using a variety of means to increase its surface energy. If they didn't do this then it could also be considered a design flaw. If they were supposed to be treated but for whatever reason your sidewall didn't get treated or weren't treated sufficiently then it would be a manufacturing defect. Its also possible that some sort of grease/oil type substance ended up on the sidewall which would stop the the glue adhering properly (manufacturing defect).
I think you might have a legitimate case for this ski failing as a result of the manufacturing or design flaw. The only problem is this is going to be very hard to prove without the right equipment. Also I don't think that there are any manufacturing standards for skis so whether they decide to replace it or not would be based on whether they thought keeping you as a customer happy is worth more than the cost of giving you new skis.
 
Back
Top