I randomly caught an episode of this show, and was incredibly confused. (The whisky didn't help.) At first I thought it was a mockumentary of sorts, or fictional to some degree.
But after reading about it online it seems like it's a real genuine thing. I guess the Amish have been rather distrustful of outside law enforcement and the mafia developed as a way to keep order and protect the community from within. However, apparently because of some their less-than-Amish activities/revenue sources, the Amish church itself denies its existence.
It was an interesting thing to watch with a buzz, but I don't see myself hunting down more episodes really. It all revolves around the pudgy ringleader and his over-eager assistants.
Storage wars however... would much rather watch that. Anytime Dave Hester gets hosed is a good day.